Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site. Learn More

2009 Harley-Davidson Sportster XR1200 Comparison

Monday, April 20, 2009
2009 Harley-Davidson XR1200 Comparison
Click to view video
The XR1200 represents Harley’s first real sport-oriented motorcycle built for mass consumption. It’s cued heavily off the XR-750 dirt track racing motorcycle that is, without doubt, the most successful flat track racing motorcycle ever built. For decades people have been trying to assemble their own home-made street-legal version of this bike. Now making one your own is only $10,799.

(See and hear Harley's new XR1200 in action in the 2009 Harley-Davidson XR1200 video to the right)

Visually the Harley-Davidson XR1200 gives off mixed signals. The thick Showa inverted fork, oversized brake rotors, stout brake calipers, and the tall triangular shape of the Dunlop Sportmax Qualifier front tire, trick you into thinking the bike is pure sport and definitely not made in America. However, as your eye moves rearward past the gas tank and onto the rear section of the bike with its twin rear shock absorbers there is no mistaking it for anything other than a Harley-Davidson. We especially dig its slick upswept exhaust that not only looks the part but sounds mean too.

Harley-Davidson Sportster XR1200
The new Harley-Davidson XR1200 represents Harley-Davidson's most sport-oriented model in its 2009 model year line-up.
Once in the seat, the ergos on the XR are a bit of a cross between that of a sport machine and standard cruiser. If you’ve logged a lot of seat time aboard other Harley’s you’ll instantly be at home on the XR. If you haven’t though, it feels downright odd. The seat itself is relatively low and positions the rider in an upright contour with the majority of your weight distributed directly to the seat.

Reach to the handlebars isn’t a stretch like it is on the Guzzi and keeps in-line with the relaxed theme, plus there isn’t a hint of pressure placed on your hands or wrists. Place your feet on the mid-mounted footpegs and you’ll notice how awkward it feels as the pegs are positioned in such a way that it feels like your feet are perched in front of you farther than they actually are.

Once you reach a curvy stretch of pavement its curious riding position suddenly makes sense. Despite its 607-pound curb weight, hustling the XR through second- or third-gear switchbacks will surprise you. At these speeds the Harley maneuvers from side-to-side with just only a light touch on the wide handlebar before falling predictably into the turn.

Aiding the H-D XR1200’s maneuverability is its traditional engine mounting position as compared to the Guzzi’s traverse engine mount set-up. This translates into a substantially slimmer chassis, which does a great job of camouflaging the XR’s mass.
The Evolution engine inside the XR1200 puts 66.6 ft-lb of torque at 4000 rpm.
The heart of the Harley-Davidson XR1200 is this 1203cc Evolution V-Twin. Harley infused it with some classic hot-rodding techniques including higher-spec cams, more compression and large throttle bodies.

“I was really surprised by how well the Harley scoots around in the corners,” said Motorcycle USA VP Ken Hutchison. “Initially when I lifted it off the kickstand I presumed that it was going to be a total pig. But that’s simply not the case.”

Once turned the Harley continues to impress with its stability. The chassis does a fantastic job of compensating abrupt brake or throttle inputs and keeps you in command even if you get ham-fisted with the controls. Simply point turn, accelerate then repeat. On the XR it’s that easy. Really aggressive riders will drag hard parts but it takes some serious speed to do so.

Out on the freeway the XR’s sporty suspension components equate to a rough ride while cruising in a straight line. Yet the seat is super plush and helps counteract the suspension’s jarring effect, making a hundred mile trip more than plausible.

Powering the XR1200 is a 1203cc Evolution engine that has some mild hot-rodding including 50mm throttle bodies, higher-spec cams and more compression, all engineered specifically for its application. Thumb the starter button and the engine rattles to life with that unique Harley thud-thud sound. At a stoplight the engine vibrates so much that the driver next to you can’t help but instinctively stare at the gyrating H-D lump.

Once the stoplight turns green, over 60 lbs-ft. of torque from just 3000 rpm make escape especially entertaining. The engine is especially apt down low in the rev range, pumping out a steady and highly useable spread of torque that makes accelerating from a standstill a blast.
Harley-Davidson Sportster XR1200
The Harley-Davidson XR1200 will suprise you with its quick handling. It's Dunlop Sportmax Qualifer tires will also take a lot of cornering abuse, however at speed the footpegs will drag on the road below.

Throttle response is also first-rate, no doubt in part to its well-sorted fuel-injection as well as the right side belt final drive, which helps make the connection between your right hand and the throttle especially precise.

“The XR’s engine comes on strong down low. It’s got so much torque right off idle that you don’t even need to give it any gas when launching from a stop. But the engine spools up slowly and power signs off way earlier as compared to the Guzzi,” stated Hutchison.

Not only does the XR’s engine spin up slowly once it gets past 6000 rpm acceleration feels like it tapers off thereby necessitating an upshift.

Fortunately, while the XR doesn’t have the top end power of the Guzzi, where it does beat it is in the transmission department. As you maneuver through all of the XR’s five gears you’ll really be amazed with how well it shifts. Gear changes are accompanied by both an audible “clunk” and a solid feel at the end of the shift lever. We do have some complaints however: First, the manual cable-actuated clutch requires way too much lever pull. Unless you’re a gym rat or blessed with superhuman arm strength working the stiff clutch quickly becomes tiresome. Plus the spacing between each of the five gears feels too wide. We would have preferred an additional final cog which might allow the individual gear ratios to be closer together.

Although the Harley-Davidson XR1200 makes use of some stout braking hardware, including three thick 292mm cross-drilled brake discs controlled by dual four-piston Nissin calipers up front with a single-piston controlling the rear disc, braking performance feels lackluster.

Slowing the bike down in a hurry requires a minimum of two fingers along with some serious pull on the brake lever. Conversely the rear brake set-up felt strong and when used together with the front brake drastically reduces stopping distances to a more acceptable measurement.
The XRs 1203cc Evolution engine will rev out to 7000 rpm.
The Harley-Davidson XR1200's minimalistic instrument display provides the rider with the bare essentials including speed, rev counter, odometer and double trip meters.

The XR’s instrumentation consists of two rounded gauges that sit atop the upper handlebar clamp. The smaller gauge to the left houses an orange-backlit digital speedometer. Next to it a larger white-face tachometer with an integrated digital odometer/trip meter and assorted engine warning lights relays information to the rider. Despite its minimalistic design the gauges are clear and easy to read day or night.

In terms of overall build-quality the Sportster XR1200 is without a doubt a quality piece of machinery. Its components have a very solid, weighty feel to them and appear very high quality. Stylish touches like the exhaust system’s satin chrome finish and the engine’s silver powder coat set it apart from other motorcycles you might see on the street.

Our biggest gripe however is the fuel filler cap. Not only is it keyless, which makes it easy for a crazy ex-girlfriend to pour sugar into the gas tank (that never happens, right?), but the unusual open/close design had me completely befuddled at fuel stops. Way too complicated.
2009 Harley-Davidson Sportster Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Slideshow
Harley-Davidson Motorcycle Reviews
2015 Harley-Davidson Freewheeler First Ride
Harley-Davidson expands its trike offerings with the all-new 2015 Freewheeler and MotoUSA takes a ride.
2004 Sportster Project: RSD ProStep Bars
We remedy the old-look of our 2004 Sportster 1200 by installing RSD ProStep Handlbars, Nostalgia 4-Bolt Risers, Avenger Levers and Tracker Billet Grips.
Harley Sportster Chopped Rear Fender Install
The stock back end of our '04 Sportster 1200 project bike was big and bulky, so we cleaned it up by installing a Harley Chopped Rear Fender and Side-Mount License Plate Kit.
2015 Harley Street Glide Special Comparison
The Street Glide is Harley's best-selling touring motorcycle, but can the 2015 Street Glide Special fend off the challenge of the powerful 2015 Indian Chieftain?
Dealer Locator
Harley-Davidson XR1200 Specifications
Introducing the 2009 Harley-Davidson XR1200.
Engine: Air-cooled 1203cc Evolution V-Twin, 4-valve Bore x Stroke: 88.90 x 96.82mm
Compression Ratio: 10.0:1
Fuel Delivery: Electronic Fuel-Injection
Horsepower: 78.6hp @ 6900 rpm
Torque: 66.1 lb-ft @ 3900 rpm
Clutch: Wet; Multi-plate; Cable actuation
Transmission: 5-speed; Belt final drive
Frame: Steel
Front Suspension: Showa 43mm inverted fork; 5.1 in. travel
Rear Suspension: Twin shock absorbers, adjustable for spring preload only; 5.0 in. travel
Front Brakes: 292mm discs with Nissin four-piston calipers
Rear Brake: 292mm disc, single-piston caliper
Tires: Dunlop Qualifer 120/70R18, 180/55R17
Curb Weight: 607 lbs.
Wheelbase: 59.8 in.
Length: 85.4 in.
Rake: 29.3 deg. Trail: 5.11 in.
Seat Height: 30.5 in.
Fuel Capacity: 3.5 gal.
MSRP: $10,799
Warranty: Two year, unlimited mileage
Colors: Vivid Black; Pewter Denim; Mirage Orange Pearl

Login or sign up to comment.

Smitster -Mr.  February 24, 2010 08:04 PM
I have had both bikes. Liked both alot. However the XR is still in th garage. It handles better and just feels better going down the road. The Guzzi is quicker and faster, but you can't push it through the turns. Also I couldn't ever get used to the shaft drive. So , of course over all I chose the XR. An all around fun bike.
Leif Myhre -Moto Guzi Griso Vs the XR-1200  June 15, 2009 07:51 PM
I own a 1000 cc Moto Guzi SP and enjoyed many miles on 883 sportster,(not to mention a ride on Dad's XR-1000 back in the day.... Can't wait to ride them both. My guess is that I will cast my lot with the Guzzi's superior roll-on power, great looks and magical twin engine... Thanks for the features. Leif
CRF450Howie -Harley XR1200  June 14, 2009 09:47 AM
I give Harley credit for an initial excellent effort. I test road this bike 09. In my opinion brakes are excellent with the front being almost too grabby. Fuel filler cap is not an issue it's just as when you used to switch from left to right side kick starters, my first attemp to open and close it was easy ( no help needed). The bike does shake like a blender while at a stop, I think they actual want this trait. The bike feels way lighter than it is when moving. My question to myself is keep the Honda 919 or switch to the XR1200. Build quality on the XR is excellent just don't know if it will shake it's self to pieces.
Tom -looks  April 24, 2009 04:45 PM
@freddie: get off the hate-train and embrace 2009, will you? Djees. "rice" burners? As their any need to polarize and ridicule the other side? Bikers sometimes just look like soccer hooligans. In my opinion? It's about freaking time harley stepped up to an audience younger than 55 with bikes other than 1950's farting relics with a redline at 4000 rpm. I'm still not totally happy with it. Too heavy for starters, and too much compromise for balanced aesthetics (there's no place for that on a naked performance bike) but it's a step in the right direction. And besides, this doesn't even look anything like Japanese bikes. It's a design and style of their own and I respect that. It clearly shows Harley heritage all over. I except a whole lot more from harley in the future. I want new engines for new cruisers. I won't even consider them with their current line up. 15 years behind the rest.
freddie belcher -bikes  April 22, 2009 08:49 PM
Why is harley trying to look like rice burners?
407Guy -"Harley sound that can hang with the sport bikes."  April 20, 2009 06:26 AM
ummm.... that's called a Buell and has been around for 25 years.