Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site.

Learn More
Shop Motorcycle Parts, Gear & Apparel at

J.D. Power 2009 Motorcycle Helmet Study

Tuesday, May 26, 2009
J.D Power and Associates 2009 Motorcycle Helmet Satisfaction Study.
J.D Power and Associates 2009 Motorcycle Helmet Satisfaction Study results.
Arai ranks highest in satisfying motorcycle helmet owners for an 11th consecutive year, according to the J.D. Power and Associates 2009 Motorcycle Helmet Satisfaction StudySM released today.

The study measures the overall satisfaction of motorcyclists with their new helmet in three key factors: ventilation, face shield, and design and styling; which consist of 11 attributes: quietness; ventilation/air flow; de-fogging; face shield ability to keep wind out; face shield ability to resist scratching; ease of replacing face shield; scratch resistance of shell; color/graphic design; weight; ease of fastening the strap; and fit and comfort.

With a score of 830 on a 1,000-point scale, Arai ranks highest and performs particularly well in the ventilation and design and styling factors. Shoei follows with a score of 815 and performs well in face shield. Icon ranks third overall with a score of 806.

“Arai continues to improve in the areas critical to customer satisfaction, which has further differentiated it from other manufacturers,” said Tim Fox, research manager of the powersports practice at J.D. Power and Associates. “Arai’s focus on fit and comfort—the most important consideration when purchasing a motorcycle helmet—and its ability to cater to different types of riders have given the manufacturer a consistent edge in satisfying customers.”

Overall satisfaction with motorcycle helmets has increased to an average of 766 in 2009—up 5 points from 2008—the highest level since the study’s inception in 1999.

The study finds that while the percentage of helmet owners who conducted research online before buying has remained relatively steady from 2008 at 36 percent, the proportion of helmet owners who purchased their helmet online has increased—up to 17 percent in 2009 from 14 percent in 2008. Additionally, those who purchased more expensive helmets ($200 or more) are more likely to both research and purchase their helmet online. More than one-half of these helmet owners researched online prior to their purchase, and 22 percent of them made their purchase online.

The 2009 Motorcycle Helmet Satisfaction Study is based on responses from more than 4,600 purchasers of new 2008 model-year motorcycles who provided information about their most recent helmet purchase experience and helmet use. The study was fielded in September and October 2008.

Login or sign up to comment.

Comments
G. Agostini -Small sample size = didn't make the list  June 24, 2009 12:31 PM
Check the fine print of JD Power results: "Included in the study but not ranked due to small sample size are: AFX, AGV, GMax, HCI, Suomy, Vega and Z1R." Harley and Icon are rated above average? Obviously, ignorance is bliss for many posers, err 'riders'.
JD Power is a Joke -2006 - 2009  June 18, 2009 10:28 AM
How could Suomy win the JD Power Study in 2009 then not even make the list this year!?!?! Icon's are garbage made by Parts Unlimited in Asia. It's hilarious that they could would be ranked 3rd!
Tony -Drivel...  June 8, 2009 03:54 AM
It must be the researcher's first project so I suppose we could forgive such absurd results on such a subjective matter. Nah, no way! My Shoei fits my head, budget and possibly my safety needs but other lids do the same. I use it rain or shine and it has minor dings in it and the visor has a few small scratches...yep, I actually use the thing and I don't store it in a glass case! This was not a study, it was a waste of money. What's next, highest rated socks based on the ease of removing them from the packet?
E.C.W -helmets  June 4, 2009 02:02 PM
Unfortunately, helmet OWNERS are a biased group. Most will not admit, even to themselves, that they've made a dumb purchase. A helmet would have to be really bad for some to pan it. Ideally, a group of riders should each test a series of helmets, in a blind test - no way to tell which brands are being tested, so no pre-conceived opinions. This test, to some extent, tells which are the most popular helmets, not necessarily the best. Recently, some enthusiast publications have done this kind of test, but it needs to be repeated on a regular basis, to account for model chnges/improvements
Derek Whelan -Helmets  June 4, 2009 02:07 AM
Shoei suits my head shape best and is quite, even better with the optional whisper kit fitted.
Bob -Harley Helmets  June 3, 2009 04:20 PM
This is a classic example of results skewed by a researcher who has failed to adequately research the subject and understand factors that will cause an imbalance in straight line tabulation. There is no evidence that the study questioned each respondent on how many helmets of what brand they had owned in their lifetime. Indeed, it is a summary of reported observations of those purchasing 2008 motorcycles on their report of their most recent helmet. For example, how many Harley buyers are purchasing their first motorcycle, or a repeat Harley purchase? How many of them have owned ANY helmet other than a Chinese made Harley brain bucket? Bogus data with no recognition of the limitations of the study.
Jeff -Comfort and Safety  June 3, 2009 09:59 AM
Missing in this discussion is that people's heads, just like their feet, are all different. Shoes are built in wide and narrow versions. Helmets are also, though not by a single manufacturer. I've found that each brand is for one shape of head - you need to find the right shape.
Dan Joseph -Helmet Comments  June 3, 2009 09:52 AM
I've been researching helmets after being out of motorcycling for a while. I have been pretty confident that the Arai Vector was the best choice so it was great to see this survey conducted as it confirms my research and decision. Thanks!
gromay -Dont know about this study  May 31, 2009 09:26 PM
i think this is more confusing then useful, in some ways it even contradicts what i have researched on the web, besides, only 4600 users were researched and if you divide them between all the brands and then between all the models of each brand you get a very little amount of owners for a particular helmet, that means your answer is not going to be truly significant. this makes this study useless and a waste of time. everybody is saying the bell star is one of the best helmets on the market yet on this study bell is at the bottom, hu???
Tony -Helmet Safety...???  May 29, 2009 01:22 AM
Erhhh... I thought the idea behind helmets is SAFETY, not looks, ventilation and how shiny it is. Or am I missing something?? Tony
Desmolicious -Arai not the best at everything  May 27, 2009 01:00 PM
I love the fit and comfort of my Arai. The only other helmet that I have tried that comes close is the Shoei X11. But the face shield change mechanism is so awful I'd never buy it again unless they changed it. It blows.
Joey.C -J D Power 2009 Helmet Study  May 27, 2009 11:02 AM
Arai are the best fit and comfort you can't beat .
Hmmmm -Shark  May 27, 2009 10:17 AM
No Shark on the list either...but my Arai has been great!
Tim B -WTH  May 27, 2009 09:33 AM
This "study" is a JOKE! KBC helmets are better than HJC? Uh no not at all.
Esteban Almeida -Bell Helmets  May 26, 2009 09:15 PM
How come bell helmets are at the bottom of the list? I just bought a bell moto-8 2008 for $200 and I just got it a week ago...I received a great helmet bag, extra visor, extra cheek pads, and obviosuly the helmet that is great...full ventilation, nice paint...the best helmet I´ve ever had! and in came down here to Ecuador!
Not very comprehensive. -All high end brands or just the most common ones?  May 26, 2009 06:28 PM
Why leave out AGV or Suomy? They don't talk much about thethe most durable (safety wise) of the bunch.

Email Newsletter
Sign-up for our weekly update.
MotoUSA Mobile
Optimized for your device.
Motorcycle Superstore
Shop with confidence - #1 rated.

Motorcycle USA covers the world of motorcycles with breaking motorcycle news, motorcycle reviews and motorcycle race coverage. When you can’t afford to miss a single event in the world of motorcycling, trust Motorcycle USA to bring you the inside scoop on the two-wheeled world.


Copyright 1996-2012 Motorcycle USA, LLC. All rights reserved.


sc