Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site. Learn More

2014 Star Bolt Comparison

Monday, May 20, 2013

Videos Our Sponsor
2014 Star Bolt Comparison Video
Click to view video
See how the 2014 Star Bolt fared against Harley's Iron 883 Sportster and Triumph Motorcycles' Bonneville in our 2014 Star Bolt Comparison video.
The Star Bolt made a positive impression during our first ride in San Diego (read all about in our 2014 Star Bolt First Ride article.) Thanks to a big front hoop, tall neck, bars with a dirt-track style bend, big V-Twin, and throaty exhaust, it’s got rockin’ style. It also taps into parent company Yamaha’s racing heritage, borrowing technology like its ceramic composite cylinder sleeves from its line of championship-winning sportbikes. Piggyback reservoir shocks and wave rotors generally aren’t standard fare on cruiser motorcycles either but are included in the Bolt R-Spec package we tested, the suspension upgrade included in the $300 R-Spec ensemble.

The 942cc V-Twin powering the Bolt isn’t anything new, the engine already in use in the V Star 950. But a new airbox, different exhaust, and new settings to the 3D mapping to both the fuel-injection and ignition timing give it a torquier delivery in the low- and mid-ranges. Crack the throttle on the Bolt and it lives up to its name. It’s snappy off the line in the first three gears, with peak torque doled out at 3400 rpm. The engine stays in the 53 lb-ft range from 3400 to 3700 rpm and still registers 50 lb-ft up to 4800 rpm, providing a very usable spread of power. Though it couldn’t hang with the Bonneville with its high-end horsepower delivery, it bested the Sportster by .49 seconds from 0 – 60mph. Though it feels like a bigger bike, it actually weighed in 21 pounds less than the densely-packed Iron 883.

“The Bolt’s air-cooled V-Twin beats the Harley with a torquier powerband. The Bolt sounds burlier, and it delivers with a more direct throttle. Unlike other metric rides, which feel detuned and mellow, the Bolt bangs out some personality, without shaking the rider around like the Sportster. Some riders will prefer the ‘character’ of the Harley, but I think the Star V-Twin is easier to live with – and more engaging,” said Motorcycle USA Managing Editor, Bart Madson.

A single-pin crankshaft and forged connecting rods provide the Bolt’s lumping character, doing so with a rigid-mounted engine serving as a stressed member. The Sportster engine is rubber-mounted yet still will shake the fillings out of your teeth at idle. Both bikes redline in first gear at almost the identical spot, the Bolt tapping out at 43mph, but the Star gets to that point quicker thanks to immediate throttle response. Unlike the late engagement in the throw of the Sportster, the clutch on the Bolt gets into the friction zone almost as soon as the lever is let out. Team that with a spot-on Mikuni closed-loop fuel injection system that’s controlled electronically and throttle position sensors that react immediately to input from a rider’s right wrist and you’ve got a bike that lunges in the lower gears every time you shift.

Heading up OR-66 on our favorite local run, the road snakes its way up the mountain with sweepers and switchbacks galore. Winter snows and slides create uneven surfaces on some sections and the road even drops a couple inches at one point, but between the nicely damped external reservoir rear shock and thickly padded seat, the Bolt offers a comfortable ride. Heading up the hill we’re able to settle into a nice flow through the turns as the bike stays stable and sure-footed at lean. The 41mm KYB fork is keeping the front wheel down better than the bouncing around experienced on the front of the Sportster, but neither matches up to the units on the Bonneville. And while the Bolt transitions smoothly and turns in with limited input, there was one point of contention Madson didn’t hesitate to comment on.

Cropped steel fenders  a 19-inch tall  12-spoke cast wheel and the drilled-out design of the chain guard  heat shield and clamp for the battery box are some of the Bolts best features.
Cropped steel fenders, a 19-inch tall, 12-spoke cast wheel and the drilled-out design of the chain guard, heat shield and clamp for the battery box are some of the Bolt's best features.
You can get into the flow of the road on the Bolt as the bike stays stable and sure-footed at lean in the turns.
You can get into the flow of the road on the Bolt as the bike stays stable and sure-footed at lean in the turns.
The Bolts V-Twin is the widest of the bunch and teamed with the big airbox makes it challenging for riders to snug up to the bike.
The Bolt's V-Twin is the widest of the bunch and teamed with the big airbox makes it challenging for riders to snug up to the bike.
We rode the trio hard around our HQ in southern Oregon to decide which urban cruiser had the edge on the road and in the twisties.
We rode the trio hard around our HQ in southern Oregon to decide which urban cruiser had the edge on the road and in the twisties.
“The Bolt’s handling is severely limited by the low pegs. We were running a far from aggressive pace and the poor Star was scoring off its pegs at an alarming rate. Keeping the pegs low may make the rider triangle more amenable to a broader range of riders, but it scrapes on virtually every corner – even routine left and right handed turns in the city caught us napping when the hard parts would touch down.”

In the braking department, the job of scrubbing speed off the Bolt is entrusted to a dual-piston caliper on the front and single-piston unit on the back, both biting into 298mm wave-style discs. At the lever and pedal riders feel the strong, progressive braking power, but they aren’t as bitey as the Bonneville’s arrangement. The one issue we had was the rear caliper’s tendency to lock up easier than the other bikes. This is exacerbated because the Bridgestone Exedra G721 tire doesn’t provide much traction during hard braking and the rear end will slide around.

Fortunately there’s no slippage when banging through some gears. Clutch pull is relatively light and the straight-cut gear dogs of the five-speed transmission click into place without fuss. It does so with more efficiency than the Iron 883 but can’t quite match the smoothness of the Bonneville’s gearbox. Still, the multi-plate wet clutch proved efficient and reliable, hitting every shift and sliding into neutral without difficulty.

As far as the rider’s triangle of the Star Bolt, the position of the seat and footpegs feels very similar to the riding stance on the Sportster, but is more open. The foot controls are also mid-mounted but are set more forward than the Iron 883 and there’s a longer reach to the handlebar. Combine seat placement that positions riders behind the tank and bars with a pretty good spread and the Bolt offers the most wind protection of the bunch at freeway speeds. Madson commented that the controls on the Bolt also feel bigger, with the Star in general feeling like a physically larger machine – from the bigger controls to the broader engine, it surprised him that the Star was lighter than the tightly compacted Sportster.

One area the Bolt feels particularly larger is between a rider’s legs. The cylinder heads on the Bolt are wide and the airbox is big so you can’t snug up as close to the bike as the Sporty or Bonnie. Your right leg presses against the airbox on the right side while the exposed cylinder head on the left side has a wire bracket to protect a rider’s leg but it digs in at the top of your calf. It also detracts from its fit-and-finish as it looks like it was placed there as a last-second decision after Star realized riders would be burning their leg on the left jug if they didn’t do something.

Speaking of the Bolt’s fit-and-finish, it has its share of both strong and weak points. On the strong side, cropped steel fenders are a bonus, especially for painting and customizing. The 19-inch tall, 12-spoke cast wheel up front is one of its notable features, as are the drilled-out design of the chain guard, heat shield and clamp for the battery box. Granted, the piggyback reservoir shocks are an unfair up-spec advantage, but the $300 price point is worth it both on the performance and styling side. The small, round bullet-shaped LEDs are compact and tidy. The Bolt is also the only motorcycle to offer four-way adjustability of both brake and clutch levers. Of the three bikes in this test, the Bolt garnered the most attention from curious onlookers by far.

One of its low points though is its all-digital speedometer. If it’s getting hit by direct sun, it’s nearly impossible to read because of the reflection coming off the shaded glass cover. The Iron 883 and Bonneville also have digital displays, but their circular speedo dials are analog and the glass is clear so you don’t experience the same problem. We already mentioned the unsightly engine guard around the left cylinder head, but we haven’t mentioned the lip of metal at the base of the tank that detracts from an otherwise attractive design. The space in front of the engine created by the awkward bend to the frame rails of the downtubes also drew questions. We believe the taillight in the middle of the rear fender, despite its cool retro look, could have been integrated into the design more cleanly.

Overall, the Bolt does an admirable job aping the Sportster without being a Sportster. Though it’s the new kid on the block, it has its own identity and appeal. Star was smart not to go overboard with badging, instead opting to let the sum of its parts speak for itself. It not only has the power edge on the Sportster, but does so with a more efficient powerplant as it got the best overall mileage and with a more responsive throttle. Even without the up-spec rear suspension, its front end has better stability over bumps and at speed. It has plenty of character in its own right and a thumping note bellows from its exhaust. It can’t match the fit-and-finish of the Iron 883, but based on the ride, the Bolt has an edge over its American counterpart which earned it second place in our Urban Cruiser Shootout.

2014 Star Bolt Comparison Photos
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Slideshow
Recent Cruiser Reviews
ARCH Motorcycle KRGT-1 First Ride
We hit the hills above Malibu as we take the ARCH KRGT-1 for a spin, a 2032cc limited-production power cruiser.
2015 Kawasaki Vulcan S First Ride
MotoUSA hitches a leg over Kawasaki's Parallel Twin-powered 2015 Vulcan S on a 150-mile ride in California's central coast for a first ride review.
2015 Indian Roadmaster Review
We've spent the last couple months and over 3000 miles in the saddle of the 2015 Indian Roadmaster, an impressive touring motorcycle with big power and premium comfort.
2015 Indian Chieftain v H-D Street Glide Special
It's a bagger battle royale as we pit the upstart 2015 Indian Chieftain against the 2015 Harley Street Glide Special in this comparison of American-made, V-Twin-powered motorcycles.
2015 Indian Roadmaster Passenger Review
Perspectives from the pillion often get overlooked in touring motorcycle reviews, so we break down the 2015 Indian Roadmaster exclusively from a passenger's viewpoint.
Suzuki Boulevard C90T B.O.S.S. Quick Ride
A quick spin around Lake Mead reveals Suzuki’s Boulevard C90T cruiser a very capable and affordable bagger.
2015 Harley Sportster 1200C vs Indian Scout
We stoke the flames of an old rivalry, pitting the 2015 Harley Sportster 1200 Custom against the 2015 Indian Scout in this comparison between American cruiser motorcycles.
2015 Harley-Davidson Road Glide First Ride
Harley's Road Glide bagger returns to the 2015 lineup with the Project Rushmore treatment and tweaks to its signature Shark-Nose fairing. Here's impressions from our first ride.
2015 Indian Scout First Ride
We channeled our inner Burt Munro during a first ride on the resurrected Indian Scout, tapping into the liquid-cooled V-Twin's claimed 100 horsepower on the roads around Sturgis.
2015 Indian Roadmaster First Ride
The 2015 Indian Roadmaster revives one of the company's most luxurious model monikers from the 1940s, and does it one better, becoming the most comfortable and touring-capable Indian motorcycle yet.
Cruiser Dealer Locator
2014 Star Bolt Dyno Chart
2014 Star Bolt Horsepower Torque Dyno Chart
     2014 Star Bolt Horsepower & Torque Curves 

Login or sign up to comment.

Bfaix22   June 23, 2014 03:45 PM
I bought this bike over the Iron 883 mostly because of looks. I had been looking at getting an Iron 883 for months while on deployment but as soon as I got back I happen to run across the Bolt and fell in love with it. The Iron 883 looks too compact for me. I hope I can explain this well enough not to confuse people... The Bolt in my opinion looks cleaner and more defined in as when you look at it you can see all the parts, whereas with the Iron 883 its all jumbled up due to it being more compact. Overall I think the Bolt looks a whole lot better. Thats just my opinion; other will still find the Iron 883 better looking and I respect that. Performance was not my main concern when buying the bike. I had a 2004 CBR600RR and if I was concerened with performance I would have kept that. I was looking for a bike I could jump on and just cruise around town and sometimes through the mountains with my wife and be a whole lot more comftorable than a sport bike. I don't care too much for the "Wannabe" comments. Sportsters have been selling well for many years and it makes since that other companies want to tap into that market. How lame would it have been if Ford was the only automobile maker out there or only one company made an SUV or something silly like that. Competition is good for the consumer. Both companies will provide better products in order to win the consumer over. Harley lovers should be glad there is a competitor; now HD will have to take their Iron 883 to another level to keep people buying their bike.
mrmarklin   May 22, 2013 01:43 PM
This wannabe will be around a couple of years until Star does another iteration (another wannabe, different name) to try once again to win the cruiser wars.