Bryan's Blog

Font Size: small text medium text large text
RSS Feeds

Harley-Davidson Might Close York Plant

Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Harley-Davidsons York Assembly Plant
I remember my visit to Harley's York plant well.
Two years ago at the 2008 Harley-Davidson press launch, we rode from Baltimore, Maryland, to York, Pennsylvania, to visit H-D’s manufacturing plant there. Harley was introducing the Rocker, there were over 35 2008 models being introduced, and Softails and Electra Glides were furiously rolling out of the plant. We toured the assembly lines, watching as the suspended frames moved from station to station as engines were mounted, wires routed, and fenders torqued down tight. I felt a sense of privilege to get a behind-the-scenes tour, to see the faces of the people responsible for the machines and noted their sense of pride as they watched us admiring the beautiful motorcycles they were crafting. Our tour was followed up by Bjorn bombing around back demonstrating Harley’s new ABS system. I have fond memories of York, and have a collector’s pin on my jacket commemorating my visit.

That’s why when I heard that Harley-Davidson might be closing the venerable plant, I was saddened. The town and the motorcycle manufacturing plant have a symbiotic relationship. When I hear York, Pennsylvania, I think Harley-Davidson. But I hear H-D is discussing closing down its York, PA, plant and moving operations elsewhere. The plant is found not to be competitive long term due to cost structures and major changes will be needed.

Workers at the York assembly plant during happier days.
Workers at the York assembly plant during happier days.
My sympathy goes out to the Harley employees who were told of the possible move at meetings Monday. They had to endure the meeting that none of us want to hear but all fear. The York plant employs over 2500. This doesn’t include the local businesses that would be affected. Its loss would be a tremendous blow to the region’s economy, a factor I’m sure Harley is painfully aware of.

But there is hope. Pennsylvania’s US senators promptly sent a letter to Harley-Davidson’s CEO urging the company not to close the assembly plant. Senators Bob Casey, Jr. and Arlen Specter, want to work out alternatives with Harley execs, including the use of federal programs. The senators noted that the company and H-D dealerships contributed nearly $500 million to the state’s economy last year.

Here’s hoping that operations at York can be restructured and refined. The workers there have been doing a stand-up job cranking out Harley’s Touring and Softail motorcycles since 1973. It’d be a shame to see all that history relegated to a small side display in the Harley-Davidson Museum.
Post Tags: Harley-Davidson, York Vehicle Operations, H-D, Touring Motorcycles, Softail
Blog Archive
2008
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Comments
Geoff's Thoughts - Unions Do we really need them?  November 18, 2009 02:12 PM
I have worked for non-union and union shops. I visited a Ford Plant in Louisville, Kentucky and watched a guy fill truck tires with air while he was sitting in a ergo-chair on his butt. He had spring loaded air hoses and as the tires went past him he popped a filler valve on the tire stem and as the tired moved down the rollers it filled with air. The air hoses were fitted with quick release pop offs so when the correct pressure was reached they popped off and came back to him. He didn't even have to get up. They came back to a central location within his reach so he could use them again. I asked him how long he had been employed there and he said 26 years. He had bid on that job because it was easy. Oh yeah this was 1994 and he was making $27.00 an hour. Unions served a purpose in 1950. We were getting more techno savy at that time and larger corporations were forming and Managment had a disconnect with their workers. The money problems that Companies face today and the reason they have so many $10.00 an hour jobs is, there is no skill set in the labor requirement to do the jobs. Higher skill sets require more money. Most factory jobs have been idiot proofed to the point were a trained monkey can do them.I will say this though, in all the unions I have been a part of they had a few good points. For the most part however, they were only there to protect the lazy ass that wanted to go to breaks and lunch 10 minutes early, come back 10 minutes late and do half the work of other people and get paid the same as you and me. As for Harley Davidson, I am sure they got fed up with the union attitude and would like to get some production for the Money they are spending.
TOM M - Harley/York  September 3, 2009 05:37 AM
I think you will find that this is the start of all HDs problems Harley Davidson Inc Executive Salaries, Bonuses, Stock Options, and Other Compensation Company Information Company Name Harley Davidson Inc Stock Symbol HOG Business Address 3700 W JUNEAU AVE MILWAUKEE, WI 53208 Industry Motorcycles, Bicycles & Parts Fiscal Year-End 12/31 State of Incorporation WI Telephone Number 414-342-4680 Proxy Statement Filing Years - 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 Harley Davidson Inc filed the compensation data below on 4/1/2008 Name and Principal Position (a) Year (b) Salary ($) (c) Bonus ($) (d) Stock Awards ($) (1) (e) Option Awards ($) (1) (f) Non-Equity Incentive Plan Compensation ($) (2) (g) Change in Pension Value and Nonqualified Deferred Compen- sation Earnings ($) (3) (h) All Other Compensation ($) (4) (i) Total ($) (j) James L. Ziemer (PEO) President and CEO 2007 $ 875,534 $ — $ 928,103 $ 1,094,065 $ — $ 1,474,000 $ 76,011 $ 4,447,713 2006 $ 824,551 $ — $ 650,568 $ 860,442 $ 989,461 $ 937,000 $ 65,431 $ 4,327,452 Thomas E. Bergmann (PFO) Executive Vice President and CFO 2007 $ 488,787 $ — $ 221,878 $ 163,787 $ — $ 34,000 $ 31,770 $ 940,222 2006 $ 370,110 $ — $ 144,281 $ 69,609 $ 310,892 $ 231,000 $ 44,117 $ 1,170,009 James A. McCaslin President and COO-Motor Company 2007 $ 495,019 $ — $ 208,426 $ 383,848 $ — $ 370,000 $ 38,005 $ 1,495,298 2006 $ 466,350 $ — $ 124,691 $ 447,741 $ 287,272 $ 471,000 $ 59,562 $ 1,856,616 Gail A. Lione Executive Vice President, General Counsel and Secretary /Chief Compliance Officer 2007 $ 387,014 $ — $ 393,376 $ 308,060 $ — $ 153,000 $ 39,759 $ 1,281,209 2006 $ 353,715 $ — $ 357,978 $ 359,472 $ 334,260 $ 173,000 $ 40,867 $ 1,619,292 Ronald M.Hutchinson (5) Senior Vice President, Product Development- Motor Company 2007 $ 346,305 $ — $ 402,134 $ 246,387 $ — $ 281,000 $ 34,958 $ 1,310,784 2006 $ 325,396 $ — $ 320,249 $ 287,763 $ 143,174 $ 247,000 $ 36,622 $ 1,360,203 (1) We have calculated the compensation related to stock and option awards pursuant to Statement of Financial Accounting Standard Number 123 (revised) (“SFAS No. 123R”). Under SFAS No. 123R, an issuer recognizes the grant date fair value of an award over the requisite service period. For purposes of this calculation, we exclude the impact of forfeitures until they actually occur. No NEOs forfeited awards during 2007. We based the fair value of stock awards on the market price of the shares awarded on the date of grant (which considers the value of dividends that the holder of restricted shares is entitled to receive). We calculated the fair values of option awards that we granted in 2005 and later using a binomial lattice model. We calculated the fair value of option awards that we granted prior to 2005 using the Black-Scholes option pricing model. Refer to Note 8 of our 2007 financial statements included in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2007, for details regarding assumptions we used to value the option awards. (2) NEOs earned non-equity incentive plan compensation during 2006 and received the awards in 2007. NEOs did not earn non-equity incentive plan compensation in 2007. (3) The amounts in this column represent the aggregate change in the actuarial present value of each NEO’s accumulated benefit under all defined benefit and actuarial pension plans (including supplemental plans) from the pension plan measurement date used for financial statement reporting purposes with respect to our audited financial statements for 2006 to the pension plan measurement date used for financial statement reporting purposes with respect to our audited financial statements for 2007. (4) During 2007, Mr. Ziemer received cash payments of $29,600 in lieu of receiving certain perquisites and personal benefits and a non-qualified deferred compensation plan matching contribution of $36,269. The remaining balance of all other compensation consists of a 401(k) matching contribution and a tax gross-up related to the value of death benefits. *The above executive compensation data is an excerpt from the proxy statement filed for Harley Davidson Inc on 4/1/2008
ron - hd problems  August 5, 2009 09:12 PM
it,s a simple thing here that has happened to hd...nobody fore seen
the massive economic downturn coming...millons have and are losing
good paying jobs and are forced to take jobs paying 2/3 less. this is
why there were 236,000 home foreclosures in may 2009/ up 26% from a yr ago....hd finance is having a huge problem with buyers defaulting
on their purchases...fact is less and less people have the money to
buy a 20,000 motorcycle..april,may and june, the peak sales months
for hd were way down this year....plain and simple the market is
shrinking fast, so, if you want to survive, you got to get small,
fast...
Tim P. - Harley/York, PA  July 19, 2009 02:22 PM
Harley Corporate has announced possible York, PA plant closing because of cost structure at York. Comments are: *CEO Wandell should show costs of all Harley plants in comparison including Kansas City, Tomahawk,WI plants, Milwaukee engine and transmission plants and Buell operations. *York,PA plant had been the catalyst for 20 years of record sales for Harley-Davidson allowing for new plants at Kansas City,Tomahawk,Pilgrim Road and Softail plant at York. *CEO Wandell says that York has to streamline operations. I know he is a new CEO, but where has he been? York has been making permanent job cuts - the Touring frame and paint shops are being shutdown and consolidated at the newer, leaner, more efficient Softail plant at York. Eventually the Touring assembly line will be consolidated at Softail plant also. The York operations has not had a chance to even calculate cost efficincies and savings with head count reductions and these consolidations and Wandell announces possible York closing. *Union knows it will have to negotiate concessions in next contract. They have seen what has happened in auto industry and across the world. Only teachers and government workers are guaranteed raises and pensions anymore. *CEO Wandell has stated that both management and union are to blame. Management for giving too much at contract negotiations, not driving and managing workforce and the union for not being flexible on job classifications, maintenance outsourcing issues, etc.. *Hey, this is the give and take of labor/management negotiations. Now that the whole world id in the tank, changes have to be made. As with everything else, when times are good and profits are up, everyone gets lazy, fat and happy - management and union both.
Kayla - How'd that work for ya?  July 17, 2009 06:51 AM
I just wonder how the strike the York HD workers held a few years ago worked for them? Apparently not too well as there is talk again on our local news about the plant being shut down. I guess it comes down to the fact they may have won the battle but ultimately Corporate is going to win the war. Corporate never forgets and this is simply the middle finger they can give the greedy employees. All the begging and whining from our State Senators won't change a thing.
Tom - HD & Unions  July 14, 2009 08:08 PM
Hey Timmy B, It is because of Unions that non union workers in this country enjoy medical benefits, good wages and a 40 hour work week (not to mention vacation and child labor laws). Union workers literally gave their blood so yahoos like yourself could enjoy fair working conditions. Unfortunately the anti worker republican party has eroded many of the gains made by unions, and they will continue to do so until all workers in this country are like the poor slobs in the southern right to work states. The trickle down theory of economics which began in the Regan era, does not work. Their is a huge disparity of wealth in this nation, which over the past 8 years has become more and more evident. Yes, buisness owners and companies do deserve to make a profit, and a good profit. But they also have a responsibility to the American Worker by providing good wages, health care and a safe work place (all fought for by unions). Take a good look at legislation that has been passed during Republican controlled White House and Congress, and you will see a windfall for Buisness and a down turn for the American Worker.
ride_free_forever - wake up America  June 19, 2009 06:35 AM
The unions have long out lived their "American Hero" banner as has Harley-Davidson outlived its last bike made in America title. Wake up and smell the coffee folks. I was raised in a union household (building and trades unions) and throughout my life I had been a part of several others (including the infamous Teamsters, UFCW (food), and Steel). I've also owned 2 Suzukis, 1 Honda, 1 Kawasaki, then a Harley, and 2 more Kawasaki's so I am not a green horn who threw his leg over a Harely because of a name and a legend (remember, legends are mostly hype). I bought my last two Kaw's at a shop that sold H-D, Yamaha, and Kaw side by side so I could compare up close (paint, chrome, workmanship, engineering technology, price, etc). I made a choice based on my real life rider experience, research, hands on comparisons, ride, feel, etc. I didn't allow a marketing pitch or unsupported legends to shove a product down my throat anymore than I would allow the media to shove a polished and packaged politician down my throat. I also am not the type who needs a product label sewn on my back to validate my existence nor do I need a stamp of approval from anyone. I am an American and my bike happens to have been manufactured in America. It was bought at a dealership keeping jobs in America. Its quality and price allow me to enjoy it more often and to spend the money saved (initial purchase and repairs) on more items that keep Americans working and the economy going. My decision helped improve my quality of life. I am the ONE responsible to do that. I do not expect my gov’t to do it for me, or my union, or the successful to bail me out. If you think for one minute that H-D can simply lower prices without addressing the cost structures that create those prices (wages, benefits, local taxes, plant operation costs, marketing costs, costs of quality, etc) or providing real value for the dollar associated with those, you are living in a world of helmet sticker logic (FTW, DILLIGAF, etc). Look at the Auto Industry in the US today and the destruction the United Auto Workers Union has created. That's right, the FACT is that the UAW is every bit as responsible for the decline of that industry as the CEO's, CFO's, COO's, etc. Why isn't the current gov't taking over the union? Why are they taking control of GM? That’s simple, the votes had to be paid for. Imposing gov’t will on executives while “requesting concessions” from the union will buy more support. When you create such a link between a controlling political party (hell bent on “wealth distribution” and gov’t control of businesses) and huge unions (which truly are big businesses in themselves, don’t kid yourself) then you are casting your vote for Socialism. This is a country based on free enterprise, innovation, and capitalism. When a company is failing, it should be allowed to fail so that a new company can surface as a leader. Competition is what drives the market. Success of the up and coming company is fulfillment of the American Dream. Wake up and smell the coffee............
toby - greed  May 21, 2009 02:46 AM
@ucking greed... unions are all about greed... line workers do not deserve to earn $50000 per year plus $100 paid benefits.. here is a message to the line workers, IF YOU WANT TO EARN THE BIG BUCKS $$$$$$ YOU SHOULS HAVE STAYED IN SCHOOL ...$$$$ hehe i guess im talking to myself, because i quite 3.5 years ago. i worked for harley as a welder and decide to go to college like the CEO'S did ......if i want to earn the big $$$$$$$$$$$$ SCHOOL IS COOL... YEAH SOMEDAY WITH MY HARD WORK I WILL SURPASS ALL THE MIDDLE CLASS.... that goes for all you lower working class folks.... go to @ucking school, stop blaming the rich for your uneducated life.
charles gibson - about the 2008110 H/D cvo sceaming eagle ultra classic ele/giuld I bought new  May 19, 2009 12:08 PM
I am having promblem with it but no one will help me with it why dose the 2009 not have the promblem but 2008 dose and went I tell the dealer they just keep saying no promblem most promblem did't happen untill the headgaskt recall was done can you help me maybe you know what is wroght and I can tell them so I can get back the power and great ride I had before this. it act like it is in limp modle all the time at a stop . It does not sound right,it act like sometime it is running on 1 cly could it be the prossecor please write back thank you charles.gibson@pgcps.org Charles Gibson sr.
HD Hater - Raymond Fulton - Union Labor  May 19, 2009 09:25 AM
Ray your world travels are very interesting credentials for a union man, but lets get one thing straight Labor Unions are a thing of the past. Long gone are the days of unsafe work environments and over worked Americans. The labor unions reward the lazy workers with the hard workers dues. Maybe if Harley made a motorcycle that was worth a damn they would be in a better position, as far as reliability you would be nuts to get a HD over a cruiser from Japan. I know this inst what the "live to ride, ride to live crowd" wants to hear but hey the truth doesn't always come with style points. Which brings up my next question, why is it that every 50 year old man that rides a HD thinks that they are some kinda bad ass motorcyclist. HD attracts some of the worst riders on the planet and they all think that the Sunday morning ride is a Halloween costume party. come on guys get over the loud pipes because they don't save lives. Most HD riders are nothing more than low life wannabes.
snowball - harleys  May 17, 2009 05:13 PM
if it were not for the unions through out the years none of the working class folks, union or not would enjoy the wages and benefits that we do the owners and ceo's would be hording it all most people dont see that they need to read their history book on earlier labor practices and abuses of workers years ago,unions level the playing field between management and workers and that is democracy.A lot of companys bring the unions on theirselves by unfair treatment of employees.For over 30 yrs.American companys have offshored,out sourced jobs overseas and this global economy has hurt america,its all been about greed nothing else!. harley needs to cut the price/on bikes
Raymond Fulton - Union Labor  May 16, 2009 09:55 PM
This is to clowns that think the unions are ruining this country. I have worked union and nonunion down here in Florida, a right to work state. I have also lived in Japan and traveled to Singapore,Korea, and the other manufacturing countries that make cheaper products such as cars, motorcycles, and T.V.s. First you can't compare our salaries to those countries, excepting Japan with its sky high housing costs, the basic cost of living is much cheaper. For instance, here in the states you have insurance and user fees to Hell and back, such is not the case elsewhere. If you think 30.00 dollars per hour is really living, your blinded by this capitalistic b.s. they feed you every day. Wake up America, other countries blatently copy our products and make them cheaper, not necessarily better. I've worked in manufacturing over 2 decades and the one killer of our sytem is lack of feedback, a customer complains, the engineers balk or do a half assed fix to maximize profit for the short term. For christ sakes can they (HD) make an exhaust that doesn't burn your right pantsleg? or a wiring harness that shows some thought and concealment? Contrary to what these owners say, most have little real true experience with their product or they're total dumbasses- and they make the real money. So, if a poor laborer is making a few bucks don't begrudge him/her, place your hate on the owners and CEO's, -Learn Chinese now, your going to need it for product information. So, next week try to fix something you see wrong, maybe that will change this economic crisis we are in.
H-D Supplier - York  May 15, 2009 02:37 PM
As a long time supplier to H-D I can testify first hand that this is a York issue as much as an overall H-D issue. My company supplies parts to all H-D facilities but only have issues at York. A week doesn't pass where we have issues with delivery,(orders wern't placed) quality (too much inventory, blame it on the supplier quality) and ridiculous requests for special packaging and terms different from all other H-D facilities. Talk to anyone in developmental purchasing in Milwaukee or Menomonie Falls and they will affirm that York is the problem child of H-D. South East Wisconsin has a couple of automotive plants vacant. Bring the Hogs Home!!!
D. Logan - What do you expect?  May 15, 2009 11:36 AM
Harley's real profits are in merchandising. It's a sad matter of fact that H-D hardly made any money at all on their bike sales. The recent economic downturn as of late has dried up discretionary incomes and loans necessary for such purchases. Harley has also been strapped by the gaurenteed 4% pay increase every year, plus 100% health care payments mandated by the latest union contracts. This I'm sure has put a severe cramp on their budgets. You think the union would have learned better, after the Catapillar plant closed in York.
Tim B - Union and Bad Management  May 14, 2009 09:41 AM
Harley is another company being hurt by the Union. Hopefully one day this country will realize the Union is not needed anymore and that it is only helping to bring this country to its knees. And Harley definitely mishandled their business by overproducing bikes and now they are paying for it and have to cut back severely.
Crunchysmooth - Tough call  May 13, 2009 07:35 PM
Each year wages, taxes, operating costs, raw materials and etc. go up but Harley sales have recently had a slow but steady decline. This is a problem most all American manufacturing businesses have been facing for a number of years now. The current recession we are in is putting businesses out of business that were otherwise surviving on very small margins. If Harley-Davidson moves the York plant operations to another state in the USA it will be a simple case of six in one hand and a half dozen in the other hand. The closing of the York plant may be unavoidable if the current economic trends continue but the real concern should not be so much about if the York plant is closed but where or when the new one will be opened. Somehow, I don’t think Harley-Davidson has the option to move operations over the border or over seas like GM and the likes are currently doing.

Add a Comment
Your Name:

Subject:

Comments:

MotoUSA Magazine
Get your copy FREE!
Email Newsletter
Sign-up for our monthly update.
MotoUSA Mobile
Optimized for your mobile device.
Motorcycle Superstore
Shop with confidence - #1 rated.

Motorcycle USA covers the world of motorcycles with breaking motorcycle news, motorcycle reviews and motorcycle race coverage. When you can’t afford to miss a single event in the world of motorcycling, trust Motorcycle USA to bring you the inside scoop on the two-wheeled world.


Copyright 1996-2009 Motorcycle USA, LLC. All rights reserved.