Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site. Learn More

Bryan's Blog

A Call for Lane-Splitting for All

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

In car vs motorcycle collisions, the cars almost always invariably win. If lane-splitting increases a rider's odds of staying alive, then why not enact it nationwide?
Last week I wrote a blog about lane-splitting possibly coming to Arizona’s Maricopa County and commented on how motorcycles can be almost invisible sitting at the back of traffic. I was echoing the sentiments of the state rep that has been lobbying to get the bill passed, Jerry Weiers, R-Glendale, who brought up the fact that a motorcyclist sitting at the back of a line of cars is very susceptible to distracted drivers.

Little did I realize the foreshadowing the blog would have. Tragically, the very next day in Phoenix, a dump truck barreled into a group of motorcyclists, killing three and injuring six others. It was a horrific scene – the riders were stopped behind a pickup and a SUV at a red light when the truck rammed them from behind. It’s a motorcyclist’s worst nightmare and left me with an empty feeling in my stomach when I heard about it.

Let me start by extending our condolences to the families affected by this tragedy. But it brings up the question – would these senseless deaths been avoided had the lane-splitting law already been in effect? Maybe three people would still be alive today.
 
Motorcyclists already ride at a disadvantage. We don’t have a cage of steel and airbags around us to deflect the brunt of an impact. We’re subjected to toxic exhausts from old diesels and carbon monoxide-spewing cars when stuck in traffic. And car drivers are more distracted today than ever. People drive down the ride holding the steering wheel with one leg, looking down while texting with one hand and holding a latte in the other. And if motorcyclists are splitting lanes, then there’s just a few less vehicles congesting the road. After I posted the blog, thanks to readers I learned that most of Europe already allows the practice and calls it ‘filtering.’ When is the US going to follow suit?

A jealous streak by the majority cage-driving bureaucrats is what I believe is the primary obstacle. Many of them already have a negative perception of motorcyclist and don’t like the fact that bikers can have a privilege that they don’t. They almost take it personally if a motorcycle squeezes through traffic to the front of the line at a red light. But I say it should be just like the helmet law - if you’re over 21 and have demonstrated basic competency behind the controls of a bike, then you should be allowed to do it. It should be up to the individual. Every rider who does is aware of the dangers. We’re putting ourselves out there in the first place, but in an auto vs motorcycle collision, who always wins? And the majority of times, most riders go with the flow of traffic until encountering gridlock. I know the issue isn’t important enough to ever come before a national vote, but tell the families of those three Phoenix motorcyclists it’s not important.
Post Tags: Lane-Splitting, motorcycle vs car accidents, Arizona lane-splitting law
Blog Archive
2012
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2008
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec

Login or sign up to comment.

Comments
Ryan -Florida Rider April 6, 2010 06:14 PM
What happens when your the First vehicle at the light. I had that happened and almost got leveled by a suburban. I think they need to push awareness at licensing and Reissuing licenses, also with harsher penalties for Red light running, Failure to yield right of way, and for causing accidents with pushing reckless driving penalties more. I sure as heck dont want to get hit on my bike ever, but still dont want it to happen when im in a car and think our punnishment system is too lenient on people not paying attention
California has it right -I thought the same thing when I heard about the Phx Accident. April 1, 2010 04:40 PM
I ride in the SF Bay area where lane splitting is common. It's perfectly safe, and while a few mirrors have been banged, no permanent damage has ever been done to me or my bike or another vehicle. The drivers around here are used to it and for the most part, get out of the way. On the freeway, I have more close calls when I'm going the speed of traffic in my lane than when I'm aggressively lanesplitting, probably because the motion makes me stand out against the background. It needs to be made legal in the rest of the country. In a few years, when drivers get accustomed to lanesplitting bikes, it will be safer than sitting and waiting with traffic.
Max -Lane Splitting March 31, 2010 12:49 PM
Tim B.. Well said but instead of punishing everyone to maximum extent of the law we should first educate them. We have the most easiest way to obtain a drivers license in the world. It is really a joke, there is hardly any drivers training and most of it you can do online. In europe most folks pay (and i use my wife as an example since she is from there) in the sometimes thousands to get a license and must drive many hours in daytime/nightime/city etc.. To get a MC licese is another ball game, more money and more training and you must work your way up from small cc eng to larger. And getting tickets over there cost alot and go against your record. So if you paid alot for a license you will have more respect for it.
The US system is a joke and that is why most folks dont know how to drive, they are mostly untrained and unpatient. If I paid $2K to get a drivers license I would surely do my best to keep it.
We are so behind the times here in the USA it really is a big joke!

zenjim -Lane splitting March 31, 2010 10:03 AM
I commute every day in Los Angeles where lane splitting is legal. My commute involves a large part of the 405 freeway which is in gridlock or near-gridlock. First, most drivers don't move one way or the other. 95% of the drivers who do react move out of the way when they see you. 5% are jerks and intentionally block your way. If you wait patiently you will pass these people in, at most, 30 seconds, so I stopped being bothered by them long ago. When I was injured and my bike was totaled (I was rear-ended at a stop light by a drunk driver BTW) I had to commute in my truck. What's interesting is that I get approximately half of the mileage in my truck that I get on my bike. Yet I ended up paying 3x the gas bill. This is because of the incredible amount of time you spend sitting in traffic. Generally speaking, on a motorcyle I am spending 1/3 the time and 1/3 the gas. If it was ileagal I'm not sure I'd have a bike as the summer would be unbareable in the heat.
And one more issue about "newbies" crashing and burning. Every day I pass bikes with "paper plates" - new riders, as well as riders with passengers, or riders who just aren't up to it, who are patiently sitting in traffic. They can lane split, but choose not to. My best friend can run circles around me at the track, but chooses not to lane split. Make it legal, allow people to make up their own minds, and let us get on with saving the planet as well as time! And don't forget to wave when they do pull over!
MotoRider -Tennessee Rider March 31, 2010 07:17 AM
I support Lane Splitting...I would ride more often if this was legal in my state. Sitting still in traffic sweating while sitting over top a hot engine, No Thanks!
AaronW -Lane Splitting Outlaw March 31, 2010 05:44 AM
I live in North Carolina, and I occasionally split lanes if I'm in stopped traffic. Car drivers hate it. I get honked at, shouted at, and I've had one person follow me to a parking lot and threaten to "shove my motorcycle up my ass". Will I continue to do it? Yes. I believe that some times it's the safest thing for me to do, especially in heavy traffic where drivers are most likely to get upset. Now I'm thinking seriously about a concealed handgun permit. I wish that people could be better drivers, and all this non-sense wasn’t necessary.
Tom -@RR March 31, 2010 01:19 AM
Are you serious? They will intentionally crowd the center line? Jealous bastards...

You should drive around in Europe for a change. If the cagers get a chance to see you (meaning: don't filter to fast) they all try to get out of your way in order not to harm a vulnerable participant in traffic.

I do it when I'm in the car, and I see it when I'm on the bike, it's often like moses splitting the sea :p And most motorcyclists thank you by extending their leg. It's mutual respect.

Of course, our vehicles are not as wide as yours are, so filtering is easier. But it's absolutely common practice and not dangerous at all. (if you don't filter at 80 mph in traffic moving at 40 mph.) Personally I filter with traffic up to 30-35 mph at a reasonable speed difference.

Also, at motorcyclists: don't startle the cagers with race spec exhaust noise or stupidly loud cans when you go past them. I'm used to it and I always check my mirrors for the bright motorcycle lights, but even I sometimes get a heart attack when these goons filter past my car window, blipping the throttle. We all respect our two wheeled friends, but don't wear out the welcome as the say ;)
Tim B -Biased Article March 31, 2010 12:29 AM
First, let me say that I am a motorcyclist and I am all for the legalization of lane-splitting. But that doesn't mean I put on blinders or avoid seeing the other side. Legalizing lane-splitting will probably kill as many people as it saves so the life-saving claim is a joke. Do you realize some people just don't have the skill to lane-split moving vehicles? And with all the idiotic car drivers out there on cell phones, doing makeup, reading maps, books, or newspapers, motorcyclists are inevitably going to get sandwiched between two cars.

What we need to do is make punishment for killing somebody on the road in an "accident" much worse. The driver of this dump truck should be tried for 3 cases of homocide and 6 cases of attempted homocide! He KILLED these people and it was his fault. He didn't stop in time most likely due to a cell phone or some other distraction. And he's going to get off with a slap on the wrist or less. WHY shouldn't a guy who failed to control his vehicle, which resulted in the deaths of 3 people, be put in jail or even face the death penalty??? I'd feel the same if all of the victims had been in cars or trucks.
RR -Lane Splitting March 30, 2010 07:28 PM
I ride in California where lane splitting is allowed. On many occassions the cages will crowd the center line just to keep you from moving ahead of them. I only split lanes at stopped intersections when there is plenty of room to do so. I also keep an eye glued to my mirror and usually try to have an escape route handy should someone come upon me at speed.

sc