Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site. Learn More

Vance & Hines Slip-On Comparison Review

Monday, May 28, 2012


Videos Our Sponsor
Harley-Davidson Exhaust Pipe Shootout Video
Click to view video
Get a feel for how these pipes sound and compare against each other in our Harley-Davidson Motorcycle Exhaust Shootout Video.
Vance & Hines has been crafting race winning exhaust systems for over 30 years. The racing powerhouse offers the Vance & Hines Twin Slash Rounds Slip-On Mufflers ($325.95) for those looking for added performance and character without shelling out a bunch of dough.
 
When we removed the Vance & Hines pipes from the box we weren’t initially that impressed. Like its Bassani and BUB counterparts the slip-ons feature an all-chrome, one-piece design but has extra parts in the form of covers that fit over the pipes. At first the covers looked like they would be quirky to install and we presumed they wouldn’t fit right without some elbow grease. But turns out our apprehension was unfounded as the V&H system was easier to install than we expected. It does require a few more minutes than the more-basic systems like the Screamin’ Eagles. Once mounted, the set-up gave the Sportster an improved look and we liked the layered design where the muffler meets the headers.
 
Although the Vance & Hines slip-ons were the second heaviest, they’re only 1 pound 4.8 ounces heavier than the class-leading BUB’s. The quality of the welds weren’t at the same level of the Akrapovic, Bassani, or BUB pipes which hurt its score in the fit-and-finish category.
 
The Vance   Hines slip-on pipes were editors preferred choice based on price  performance and overall character.
To our surprise the Fit-and-Finish of the Vance   Hines pipe was slightly below some of the competition.
To our surprise the Fit-and-Finish of the Vance & Hines Twin-Slash was rated slightly below some of the competition.
When tested on the dyno, the Vance & Hines product posted respectable power numbers. Right off the bottom torque production wasn’t as stout as the Screamin’ Eagles or Bassanis but is close. The torque dyno chart reveals a dead flat torque curve that peaks at 4300 rpm with 69.91 lb-ft of force (third highest). Horsepower was good too with a 10 hp increase over stock to the tune of 67.47 ponies at 5900 rpm. That’s only 1.19 hp behind the class-leading Bassanis and only 0.05 behind the BUB’s, which slotted it in third place again.
 
On the road the pipes emit a classic exhaust note. At idle they sound louder than both the Akrapovics and Screamin’ Eagles though results of the sound test reveal a similar decibel rating (87 dB). As long as you avoid full throttle acceleration the pipes are actually pretty mellow sounding, but the second you go wide open the pipes burst alive and deliver a tone that is loud but not quite as obnoxious as the Bassani or BUB equivalents. Engine fueling was acceptable but the jetting wasn’t as perfect as the Bassanis which equates to some back firing during deceleration.
 
When the dust settled the Vance & Hines pipes finished in the runner-up spot courtesy of its least expensive price tag and overall preference scores. But the lower quality and mid-pack scores in other categories held it back from a better result. If Vance & Hines could boost quality and squeeze out just a hair bit more performance there’s no doubt they could be a winner.
 
The Vance & Hines Twin Slash Rounds Slip-On is available at Motorcycle Superstore starting at $293.99

RIDER NOTES:

“These are the pipes Screamin’ Eagle should have built. The pipes looked pretty janky when we unpackaged them but they fit up perfectly on the bike and have a clean look when mounted. The sound is similar to stock and the Screamin’ Eagle pipes, only throatier. These pipes have the ideal blend of sound between the stockers and the overly loud Bassani or BUB. Jetting seemed off though as the bike back fired a lot off the throttle but power was still great. Overall these were probably my favorite in terms of character/performance.”



Harley-Davidson Pipe Shootout Photos
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Slideshow
Vance & Hines Highs & Lows
Highs
  • Most affordable
  • Great character and sound 
  • Above average performance
Lows
  • Fit-and-Finish could be better
  • Could be lighter
  • More parts mean longer installation time
Recent Cruiser Gear Reviews
Icon 1000 Hood Jacket Review
For the last couple of months we've worn the Icon 1000 Hood Jacket almost daily. Here's our review of Icon's top-shelf motorcycle jacket.
ABUS Detecto 7000 RS1 Lock Review
We test the ABUS Detecto 7000 RS1 brake disc lock, which boasts a 3D motion sensor alarm and hardened steel reinforcement.
Wulfsport Kit Bag Review
If you're looking for a bag big enough to fit all your racing gear and then some, check out the Wulfsport Kit Bag.
Vance & Hines - Slip-On Mufflers
Superstore Price: $293.99 - $422.99
 

Login or sign up to comment.

Comments
piyushthakran   April 7, 2014 09:07 AM
Wanted to know whether the road test was with stock air filter and no fuel pak. if yes, whether there is any adverse impact on the engine by using these exhausts??
ffarmeer   May 30, 2012 01:37 PM
I'd be curious to see the "lab" conditions. It appears to me that this is an opinion piece. Not a real test. Thank God we have better reciew to make our decisions with.