Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site. Learn More

Study Proves Off-Road Knee Braces Effective

Tuesday, February 15, 2011
EVS Web Knee Brace
Turns out that strapping on a knee brace really does help.
A recent study performed at the Sanders Clinic for Orthopaedic Surgery and Sports Medicine in Houston, Texas indicates that the use of protective knee braces lowers the risk of knee injuries. Researchers conducted an online poll which qualified 2115 off-road motorcycle riders who supplied data over the course of one year.

The study uses the term “prophylactic knee braces” which is defined as “any knee brace worn by a rider with the intent of preventing an injury to the knee.” Riders were divided into categories of braced and nonbraced and they recorded the number of hours riding and any qualifying injuries suffered to their knees. Bruises, scrapes and sprains don’t count, only “acute trauma to 1 or more of the 4 major knee ligaments (ie, anterior cruciate ligament [ACL], posterior cruciate ligament, MCL, and lateral collateral ligament); as a meniscus tear; or as acute trauma to the femur, patella, tibia, or patellar ligament.”

Here’s a portion of the abstract as published in the American Journal of Sports Medicine. Researchers include Mark S. Sanders, MD, Robert A. Cates, BA, Michael D. Baker, BS, Sue D. Barber-Westin, BS, Wesley M. Gladin, BS and Martin S. Levy, PhD. 

Results: Participants recorded 39 611 riding hours over the study period. A total of 57 riders (2.7%) sustained at least 1 knee injury, for a total of 89 injuries. The most common injuries involved the anterior cruciate ligament, menisci, and medial collateral ligament. There was a significantly higher rate of overall injuries in the nonbraced group versus the braced group (3.675 vs 1.587 per 1000 rider hours, P < .001). Significantly higher incidence rates of anterior cruciate ligament rupture (1.518 vs 0.701 per 1000 rider hours, P = .0274) and medial collateral ligament injury (0.799 vs 0.111 per 1000 rider hours, P = .002) were found among nonbraced riders compared with braced riders.

The Moment of Truth. This photo happened to capture the exact moment when Brians knee transitioned from healthy and strong to mushy and useless.
Racing and riding off-road motorcycles is hard on the entire body, but knees are especially vulnerable.
Conclusion: The most common knee injuries in off-road motorcycling involve the anterior cruciate ligament, menisci, and medial collateral ligament. The use of prophylactic knee bracing appears to have a beneficial effect in preventing medial collateral ligament and anterior cruciate ligament injuries as well as overall knee injury occurrence. These findings may be applicable to other sports that involve similar forces and mechanics. “

While the news is positive and goes to show that the development of protective equipment is making a difference, poking through the statistical data allows us to pull some other interesting conclusions. Of the riders sampled, the largest group are over 35 years of age. Those riders also sport the highest percentage of brace wearers (69%). So are we smarter with age, or simply more fragile? Also, riders with only 1-5 years of experience have the lowest percentage of brace wearers (54%). The longer we’re in this sport, the more injures we experience personally and with other riders. Does this indicate a need for better education and awareness about dirt bike protection? Or perhaps lower prices to help get entry riders geared up. Also, 74% of recorded motocross riders wear braces – the highest of the listed disciplines.

There’s an old saying that there are two kinds of riders – those who have had knee surgery, and those who will. A sport-specific study like this is a valuable tool for providing feedback on a controversial subject. Anyone who has twisted a throttle knows that riding dirt bikes is hard on the body, especially the knees. Even though knee braces cannot prevent all injuries, the data suggests that strapping on a set will at least improve the chances of keeping those important joints in one piece. Read the full article in this PDF file.


Other Dirt Bike Feature Articles
2015 Yamaha WR250F   YZ250FX First Look
Yamaha revealed two new off-road machines during the 2014 AIMExpo, both based on the championship-winning YZ250F, the trail-ready WR250F and cross country racer YZ250FX.
2015 Suzuki DR-Z70 First Look
Your little buddy finally has something to play with on the trail as Suzuki returns its entry-level DR-Z70 to its 2015 line-up after a few year absence.
2015 Yamaha Off-Road Line First Look
Yamaha brings back its line of off-road motorcycles for 2015, with models for the youngest and newest riders as well as mounts for those with more aged and experience.

Login or sign up to comment.

Comments
Chilly   February 15, 2011 04:45 PM
I was actually one of the participants in the study. Knee braces can not protect from every possible injury, but I am a big believer in them.
Hilde44   February 15, 2011 03:55 PM
Having yet to finish my PHD as well, here are the basics. Remember that ligaments connect bone to bone (tendons connect bone to muscle).

Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) - One of two ligaments located in the center of the knee that stabilize movement front-to-back.

Medial Collateral Ligament (MCL) - Ligament located on the inner edge of the knee that connects the femur (thigh bone) with the tibia (shin bone) to stabilize movement side-to-side.

Menisci (plural for meniscus) - Shock-absorbing pads between the femur and tibia

Basically, all of these are soft tissues that are susceptible to tearing, either partially or completely. Once torn, they do not regenerate themselves, which means surgery is the option for fixing them. It's possible to live and ride without getting them fixed, but it hurts like the dickens and instability in the knee makes it tough to have confidence in any sporting atmosphere. Surgery generally equire lengthy recoveries. I'm 14 months post ACL replacement, cleared by the doctor to ride, actively rehabilitating/exercising and it's still not as good as it was. Also of note, I was wearing a top-shelf brace at the time of injury...

Check out this link for a basic anatomy of the knee joint
http://www.aclsolutions.com/anatomy.php


a   February 15, 2011 01:45 PM
JC, I'm not a doctor, so in internet dummy terms, " The most common knee injuries in off-road motorcycling involve the anterior cruciate ligament, menisci, and medial collateral ligament." and this is..?