Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site. Learn More

Single Track Mind: War Clouds in the Horizon

Tuesday, November 1, 2011
In recent years motorcycles have become easy targets for safety legislation.
In recent years motorcycles have become easy targets for 'safety' legislation. Will the law get less friendly in the U.S.?
I am starting this column with a real sense of unease because I am all too well aware of how much readers dislike me discussing politics in a motorcycling feature. Regardless, it is a subject I need to address because riders all over the world are in real danger of being legislated out of existence. This is not a hyperbole, but a hard, cold fact.
Currently, the greatest problems facing riders are in the European Union. Originally, the 27 countries which make up the EU were a free trade organization but now there is an increasing impetus toward a forced political integration which will, in the dreams of the Eurocrats, form a European super state to rival the United States of America.
Why should this be of the slightest interest to you as you head off to Laguna Seca for MotoGP, or smell the sweet air of the high desert as you ride your Tiger 800 to Denio Junction?
To answer this question we need to look at history. Toward the end of their lives, all great empires become ossified by their increasingly effective Civil Service. In simple terms, the administrative weight destroys them. The Western world represents a unified empire and, as even a cursory reading of history tells, is now coming to the end of its life.
However, before an empire’s demise comes a period of intense bureaucratic activity. This is the epoch we find ourselves in at present.
There are several ways to look at the situation. The easiest and most attractive approach is to get on our bikes and do nothing; stick our fingers in our ears, shut our eyes and just hope it will all go away. But it won’t.
The second way is to rage and foam and vent our spleen by writing invectives to motorcycling websites and magazines. This gives the impression of doing something when the only value is cathartic in that it makes the individual writer feel better.
Finally, there is the hard and rocky route which has no interest for any us: the hard slog of politicization.
Let’s look at why bureaucrats want to kill motorcycling through legislation. First and foremost they live in the land of milk and honey. Here are some interesting facts about the Eurocrats who are the real legislative power in Europe.
Did you know that 40% of all EU Officials earn more than $100,000 a year?
Since much of the community is against bikes and bikers it has become increasingly easy for politicians to pass anti-motorcycles policies.
Since much of the community is against bikes and bikers it has become increasingly easy for politicians to pass anti-motorcycle policies. This is why activism amongst two-wheeled enthusiasts is more important than ever.
If you happen to be a non-Belgian – the European Parliament is based in the Belgian capital, Brussels – you will get an additional 15% ‘Foreign Service Allowance.’ You could live just over the Belgian border in France, Luxembourg or the Netherlands but you will receive the 15% bonus.
As an EU official your minimum holiday entitlement will be 42 days a year – obviously plus public holidays – but if you’re so kind as to work slightly outside your official 37-hour week you’d be entitled to a further 24 days’ paid vacation.
This point needs stressing: As a Eurocrat you can legally and happily be absent from your post for a minimum of 13 working weeks every year, plus public holidays.
You will also enjoy free private schools for your kids, subsidized travel and a breathtakingly generous pension.
Now I would like to say that this is a problem unique to Europe, but I would bet my G.50 against an unfair parking fine that the same situation applies to Capitol Hill. In short, bureaucrats are doing extremely well throughout the world. There is another problem. Administrators are very good at administration. I used to do quite a lot of work with Government Ministers in Britain, and believe me their staff are stunningly intelligent and as sharp as a well-honed Bowie knife.
They also know all the systems by which a country – any country - is governed and, by contrast, we are complete and utter amateurs at the political game.
Finally, they are pushing on an open door in terms of choking motorcycling to death because much of the community is against bikes and bikers. Imagine having a barbecue in your backyard on Sunday afternoon and being deafened by the local bike club roaring past on un-silenced V-Twins. It’s easy to dislike such a clearly identifiable group.
Now, let’s have a look at what’s called ‘Realpolitik’ in the political trade. It’s a German term which means manipulating the masses to achieve your end.
The first step is to make sure that you protect your position. In the case of bureaucrats you need to continue legislating in order to keep your job. If this sounds almost childishly simple, ask yourself one simple question: What would you do to keep a job which paid $100,000, gave you 12 weeks holiday a year and a 37-hour week? If you could keep your job, and stomp on a particularly unpopular segment of the community – and get praised for your zeal – how good would that be?
Riders need to look no further than the defeat of the lead ban on youth model ATVs to see how important their vote is.
Riders need to look no further than the defeat of the lead ban on youth model ATVs to see how important their vote is.
Next, you have to generate ‘evidence’. This does not have to be empirical evidence, subject to peer review, but any survey which produces the results which you need. Let me show how this works in practice. A few years ago one of the areas near to us undertook a piece of research to find out how many people found stepping in dog droppings unpleasant.
In a way this was a surreal experience because 6% of those surveyed actually didn’t mind, which shows that the English are either incredibly tolerant - incapable of understanding even the simplest question when posed by a researcher - or have some quasi sexual fetish for having canine feces on the bottom of their shoes.
With motorcycling you find out how many people would like to see fewer riders killed on the roads and, therefore, a reduction in the number of orphans and widows.
So now you have a mandate: reduce the accident rate amongst motorcyclists.
You then go to your political masters and say to them: “Minister, are you in favor of reducing the number of motorcycle fatalities, or would you prefer to see an increase in the number of orphans and widows which will have been caused by your inaction.”
And don’t believe that this doesn’t happen in real life – it does!
Now we’re getting somewhere. You have the ‘evidence’ which shows that motorcycling is unacceptably dangerous and your political masters have given you the green light to reduce the death rates and thus protect the future orphans and widows. Happy days all round.
This is the state of affairs in which we now find ourselves in Europe. There is a veritable tsunami of measures planned to restrict the right of the motorcycling communities, and most are ‘safety’ focused. There is also a bonus available to Eurocrats. ‘Safety’ standards can be raised whilst protecting polar bears and penguins from dying through the global warming caused by naughty motorcyclists. Truly, a double whammy!
How would you like it if the government required you to wear a high visibility vest in order to ride a motorcycle
High visibility vests might aid in rider safety, but should it be mandatory law in order to operate a motorcycle?
Some of the most pernicious new laws are those planned by Irish and French governments. Both of these countries are now implementing legislation which would require riders to wear high visibility clothing at all times. Now you might think wearing a high vis vest is a good thing or, like me, a waste of time – but do you want to be told that you will ONLY be allowed on the road if you wear prescribed clothing?
No more riding to the race track in your stylish leathers, unless they are covered in fluorescent plastic. No more nipping down to the store for a bag of cookies in your jeans and t-shirt. In fact, you will not ride anywhere unless you dress as the government dictates.
The ‘evidence’ for these laws was infantile. Surveys asked if it was easier to see someone standing still in a high vis jacket or a black one? Once again, this was dog poo research in action.
There was no attempt to see whether a rider was more visible or if there was any evidence that motorcyclists wearing high visibility clothing were less likely to be hit by drivers. These regulations have been brought into law simply because of the belief that this might be a good thing. In any case, who cares? Motorcyclists are an easy target.
Once these regulations have been enacted by the French and Irish governments, Eurocrats will seek to have the rules implemented throughout in pursuit of the Holy Grail of Harmonization.
Meanwhile, Eurocrats are demanding a whole raft of measures throughout Europe to ensure that riders are ‘environmentally aware’ and that motorcycles are ‘made safer’. First, it’s the environment. It is proposed that exhausts will only be allowed to be replaced by OE manufactured units – nothing else will be acceptable.
The same will apply to ECUs and a bike’s fuel injection system. Both will be tamper proof and will be locked to manufacturer specification.
Do you like to do a bit of maintenance? I do, but I wouldn’t be able to under this legislation. Frangible bolts, which can only be removed by a dealer with special tools, will prevent any part being changed and all the electronics will be locked down and accessible only to authorized dealers.
Some of the new measures being looked into throughout Europe include tamper proof designs which can only be altered by manufactures. Kiss your own modifications goodbye!
Some of the new measures being looked into throughout Europe include tamper proof designs which can only be altered by manufactures. Kiss your modifications goodbye.
Not even professional shops will have access to the code unless they are approved, so forget that ex-race team genius mechanic working on your bike.
Even the size of tires will be prescribed and your bike will be subject to roadside inspection, and confiscation, if you do not comply.
And if you think that all of this is of no interest to U.S. riders you’d be wrong. Bureaucrats are now part of a world-wide community, and once the idea of raising safety through high visibility clothing or enforcing anti-tampering regulations has been introduced in one part of the world, it won’t be long before everyone else seeks to catch up.
So is it all doom and gloom? Well, ironically no. Let’s start at the beginning again. You may have a painfully low opinion of your Congressman or Senator. You may think that he or she is a power-mad ingratiate with the sexual morals of an alley cat and the fiscal probity of Al Capone, but they represent the best political system in the world: one person, one vote and what passes for free and fair elections. Having worked in the old Eastern Bloc countries under Communism, I know that our democracy is truly a thing of beauty and wonder. Better still, politicians live in fear of you – they truly do.
I don’t know what the math is in the U.S., but when I worked with British politicians 50 letters from constituents on a single issue was a major post bag. The reason is simple. Ordinary, normal, sane people are not interested in politics and, therefore, it is unusual when they are roused.
Look at the success achieved from fighting the Lead Ban. Another ‘safety’ measure designed to reduce the pool of potential motorcyclists was, through the outstanding efforts of the AMA and individual riders, revoked.
Surprisingly, it is quite easy to persuade politicians that anti-motorcycle legislation is bad for them. Motorcyclists can be quickly mobilized to become single issue voters. In practice this means that voters will ignore a politician’s stance on the economy, education, immigration and a whole stack more measures if they are angered by a single issue which damages motorcycling.
If politicians can be made to have genuine fear of losing votes over complete and utter non-issues like changing the oil filter on your bike or wearing a high vis vest, they will make their displeasure known to administrators and the proposed laws will simply disappear like snow in the Spring.
In parallel with rider action  we have to have a trans-national organization funded by manufacturers which will lobby politicians in every country in the world.
"In parallel with rider action, we have to have a trans-national organization funded by manufacturers which will lobby politicians in every country in the world."
So what happens now? First, every rider – dirt bike, cruiser, AT, classic and sport bike – must be sensitive to any potential legislation which affects motorcycling. When you do see anything on the horizon, write to your representative at the state and national level and express your hostility to the measure.
Then spread the word through social networking, the media – both motorcycling and general – so that everyone else knows what is happening.
In parallel with rider action, we have to have a trans-national organization funded by manufacturers which will lobby politicians in every country in the world.
Again the numbers are fascinating. The gossip is that Honda spends around $300 million racing MotoGP and Yamaha a bit less. Just think what an international lobbying group could do with 10% of this. With a fund of $50 million every piece of anti-motorcycling legislation in the world could be fought. Once administrators know that motorcyclists are not an easy target they will move on to horse riders, lawn mower operators, skunk breeders or mushroom gatherers - and leave us alone.
Once more, America provides the lead. Just look at the NRA for a model of successful lobbying.
I realize that this has not been a STM of joy and happiness, but thanks for reading it. We all need to pull together on this one. Now, I’m off to the workshop to change a faulty fuel tap on our G.50 – without safety goggles or fluorescent pink overalls - but definitely with a huge smile!
Single Track Mind Photo Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Slideshow
Recent Single Track Mind Articles
Single Track Mind: Staying Honest
Tired of seeing the history re-written, our man Melling takes vapid nostalgia to task with an honest evaluation of classic bikes both past and present.
STM: Melling Conquers LEnduro des Sables
Our man Melling recounts his poorly informed decision to enter the 1978 L'Enduro des Sables and the chaos that followed.
STM: Sammy Miller Motorcycle Museum
Our man Melling pays a call to the Sammy Miller Motorcycle Museum one of the world’s great collections of historic motorcycles.
Christmas Gifts for Your Loved One
Ye old Melling once again delivers his annual holiday gift guide for rider, which is certain to bring Yuletide marital bliss… or disaster.
STM: Storm Clouds on the Horizon
Our man Melling continues to ruminate over the future of professional motorcycle racing, and missed PR opportunities from the MotoGP ranks.
The Belgian Classic TT at Gedinne
The Belgian Classic TT at Gedinne provides a sublime road racing experience for those daring enough to take on the 3.14 miles of tight, twisting roads. Our man Melling accepts the challenge...
Single Track Mind: Is Marquez Too Good
Our man Melling wonders aloud if MotoGP wunderkind Marc Marquez is too good for GP racing. Then, ever the pragmatist, he comes up with an elegant solution to keep the Spaniard distracted.
STM: Greatest Motorcycle Racing Achievement
Our man Melling makes the case for the greatest motorcycle racing achievement ever, Jim Redman's triple win at the 1964 Dutch TT. Redman himself then steps in to recount the event.
Single Track Mind: Interesting Times
Our man Melling goes on ranting and raving again about global warming, Health & Safety bureaucrats and his idol Mike Hailwood – as well as continuing to prophesy about Grand Prix motorcycle racing.
STM - MotoGP Rules Update Rumors
It’s April Fools, almost… Our man Melling gives a rather tongue-in-cheek prediction about forthcoming MotoGP rule changes, including the esoteric algebra that will calculate appropriate rider performance handicaps and airtime.
STM: A Little Knowledge is a Dangerous Thing
Classic motorcycles can sometimes fetch a premium price, but just as often they end up costing more than they're worth. Our man Melling explains...
Single Track Mind - Mellings Best of 2013
Our man Melling applies his sage motorcycling wisdom to the passing year in New Year's installment of Single Track Mind.
STM: Christmas Gifts for Riding Partner
There are holiday gift guides, and then there are holiday gift guides penned by Our Man Melling – enjoy the read, but follow his advice at your own peril!
Single Track Mind - How Much is Too Much
Our man Melling meditates on motorcycles, Midwestern smorgasbord’s, the Honda Grom and taser-wielding bike cops.
Single Track Mind - MotoGP Has to Change
As the Melling household prepares for the MotoGP visit to Silverstone, Frank files another missive toward Dorna and its handling of World Championship motorcycle racing.
STM: Crutchlow at Ducati - Why the Surprise
Cal Crutchlow’s move to Ducati was long predicted by our man Melling, who predicted his fellow Brit’s motives months ago. Here’s why.
Single Track Mind - A First World Problem
Melling faces a "first world problem" and parts with a beloved friend, but then finds a first world solution that opens a new chapter in his racing life.
Single Track Mind: Go Racing in 2013
Our man Melling, in his quest to inculcate a new riding generation, shares some insight on ways to race without having to break the bank.
STM - Evangelize for Biking
Our man Melling is a motorcycling evangelist. In this sermon he serves up 20 points of wisdom on how to run a successful motorcycle event that will grow ridership and the sport of motorcycling.
Single Track Mind: Riding Thru 2012
Our man Melling ponders yet another year in the saddle and looks to the future. Also, trades barbs with fun-hating EU technocrats!
Single Track Mind: Wanderin Brain
Our man Melling ponders his role as motorcycle racing seer, having predicted the MotoGP rule changes recently imposed and those to come. He also terrorizes innocent hikers…
STM: European Grand Tour Thoughts
Our man Melling weighs in on the troubling future for motorcycling and its aging demographic during a grand European tour.

Login or sign up to comment.

dragonlady   December 21, 2011 07:15 AM
You have some good point; i.e., loud pipes, etc. But the only reason I read the whole article was to SEE your point. Europe is a bad example, especially now; and trashing their governors doesn't help. Look at our SUVs and increasing amount of sports cars, we're not them; in spite of our government's view of green! AND, the picture of the GI wearing proper Personal Protective Equipment, is a really good example against your argument; he has no choice. I'm a Motorcycle Safety Rep on my Air Force Base and the military as a group have been losing military members 26 and under by the dozen. It has made the DoD look at motorcycles and motorcycle riders differently; 2011 is the Year of the Motorcycle; there are Riding Courses on practically every base, as much to change attitude as to increase skill. Your fiery rhetoric only makes a good bar argument; try sticking to the facts. Labels and wild stories are why those who don't ride look at those of us who do as potential Hells Angels!
Piglet2010   November 20, 2011 06:00 AM
Glen is correct. The pretend outlaw bikers with their loud pipes may well result in legislation making them (*and* more socially responsible motorcyclists) real outlaws.
Glen   November 5, 2011 08:32 AM
Some riders choose to make all motorcyclists look bad and make it easy for the left or right governmental bureaucrats to implement the rules that hurt the sport. This my come as a shock to some but loud pipes piss-off other motorists. No helmets on kids riding ATVs in the front yard don't help much either.
GoThereat50   November 3, 2011 07:13 AM
Thanks Frank. It may not be a pleasant read but it needed to be said. For proof look no further than the so called "Lead Ban" legislation that instantly made the sales of all new youth motorcycles illegal in the US. You chose a good example to illustrate the point. I am an AMA member and use the Rapid Response links to contact US officials on legislation harmful to motorcyclist. It works, several legislators have gotten back to me on these issues. I wish more riders would do this before we are legislated to outlaw status.
C14user   November 2, 2011 09:38 AM
kmkindred, kmkindred (sigh), oh please do tell what points of Mr. Melling's article are so wrong? Your attack (sigh, right wing rants, right wing view,facile, misguided, I won't even try, kind of crap, slobbering, extreme, stick to), on Mr Melling, is nothing more than what you said you didn't want- a left wing rant! Next time try making an argument if you can. Teacher indeed.
MROPhilippines   November 2, 2011 08:50 AM
Man o man Frank! If you have it bad there, you can only guess how bad it is here in the Philippines... Name it, we have it... Motorcycle lanes that are also used by almost every vehicle in the highway Plates on helmets to curb crime No more tinted visors to identify would be criminals Subjective apprehension of open/loud mufflers Color coded helmets based on where you live Currently, we are fighting against the motorcycle lanes because of lack of preparation, safety and unequal treatment on the road. I cannot tell you how crazy it is right here. I'd like to write the whole story here, but I would rather you see everything through my blog... www.bikerpinoy.blogspot.com. I'll try to copy my stuff here too... Thanks and more power to ya and God Bless us from the totalitarian rule against bikers...
kmkindred   November 2, 2011 06:02 AM
Frank, Frank (sigh). I like motorcycling because we can forget about what divides us and concentrate on what unites us (our love of motorcycling). Warn us about legislation that puts at risk our love of riding, but please leave your right wing rants out of it. I'm a government and history teacher (in your right wing view, I guess that would make me a bureaucrat, as I work for the public sector, but then again so do cops and fire fighters). I can't begin to point out all the facile, misguided - and in some cases, just plain inaccurate -arguments you make with regards to your historical and political analysis, so I won't even try. But the bottom line is you should have stuck to your gut feeling and left this kind of crap out of the article(I don't want left wing rants, either). There was a way to inform us of the issue without slobbering your extreme political ideology all over us. Stick to something you know in this public forum, Frank (motorcycles).
guambra2001   November 1, 2011 05:16 PM
Thank you for the article, as a motorcyclist I like to keep up with the issues that might be affecting my right to ride. I chose to become a member of the AMA as a small way of doing something to prevent the legislators from killing motorcycles or the way we go about them. Anyways keep up the great work.
Thewall67   November 1, 2011 02:58 PM
Spot on Frank! This story needed to be written (although it shouldn't be new news to anyone involved in our hobby). When I got into motorcycles 10-12 years ago one of the first things I noticed is how many people were out to get me off the road, out of the dirt, etc. I was shocked because I thought the safety patrol only rallied against hunting and gun enthusiasts. Turns out there are groups of people who want to stop you from doing nearly anything that is enjoyable. My guess is if I took up scuba diving tomorrow someone would be out to stop me from doing that too. You could not have cited a better example of enthusiasts banding together to protect their interests than the NRA. Regardless of your view on guns and hunting, the NRA is an example of what the power of special interest groups can do. It isn't only the greenies and safety nazi's who can use special interests to lobby congress.

Most importantly you point out to GET INVOLDED! Write a letter, stay aware of issues; it does not take much of your time. Heck, the AMA, Blue Ribbon Coalition and other organizations go out of their way to make it easy for you to contact your legislatures on issues and keep you informed about what is going on. Get involved or one day you will wake up to find you cannot ride your motorcycle at all. You'll go in the house complaining about how stupid politicians and the safety nazi’s are when all along you could have been doing something to prevent it.

spokes100   November 1, 2011 02:41 PM
you are 100% right