Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site. Learn More

2010 Adventure Touring Shootout

Monday, September 27, 2010

There’s no shortage of adventuresome motorcyclists, but just how far each is willing to go varies widely. With that in mind, we rounded up three of the more free-spirited street bikes and took them on a three-day tour that covered hundreds of paved miles, and an almost equal amount of dirt. Three riders carried everything we needed in the saddlebags and switched between bikes as we tracked fuel economy, performance, comfort and character along the way.
Videos Our Sponsor
2010 Adventure Touring Shootout Video
Click to view video
Watch our Adventure Touring bikes in action as the Ducati Multistrada 1200 brings a new challenge for the BMW R1200GS in the 2010 Adventure Touring Shootout Video.

These are not dirt bikes, nor dual-sports. With real-world customers in the saddle, they spend the majority of their time on pavement. However, they differ from the ultra-touring bikes like a Goldwing, cruiser touring like the Victory Vision and sport touring like the Yamaha FJR. Unlike those genres, which leave no question as to their intended purpose, Adventure Touring bikes fill all of the street roles – and they’re expected to comfortably navigate the Bolivian Death Road. Despite all the marketing hype, they’re designed to spend the vast majority of their life on pavement. That pavement might be buttery twisties, hacked-out superslab or gritty, pothole-infested single-lane, but that’s the truth of the matter. We took them on a street ride, and then ventured off-road, not because they must, but because they can.

2010 BMW R1200GS
The BMW GS is the quintessential ADV bike. It’s celebrating its 30th anniversary and historically has defined a category that defies definition. It has topped countless shootouts and comparison tests, proven itself to a loyal customer base and has been BMW’s most successful model in the
Ducati MTS 1200
Triumph Tiger 1050
The three competitors come from different
backgrounds. BMW is the established king,
Ducati is a hungry challenger and Triumph
is a grizzled vet.
entire German motorcycle lineup. For 2010, the Beemer gets mild updates. Our 2010 BMW R1200GS Adventure First Ride was hardly suitable as a complete test, so we were anxious to get the accomplished adventurer back to our regular stomping grounds for a full review.

2010 Ducati Multistrada 1200
This bike is really what prompted the shootout. With a complete redesign for 2010 the new MTS 1200 has been getting rave reviews, including our own introduction during the 2010 Ducati Multistrada 1200 First Ride. The Ducati comes in flexing its considerable muscle with an 1198cc, Desmodromic L-Twin engine sourced from the race-winning Superbike. Ducati shipped us the S model (Ohlins suspension and standard ABS) with the touring kit (side panniers, heated grips and center stand). Our top-of-the-line machine comes with an elevated price tag, but we didn’t show it any special treatment, in fact it got dinged in the Price category.

2010 Triumph Tiger 1050 
Triumph is due for a redesign on the Tiger 1050, and that’s probably what we’re going to see this year or next. We plucked the 1050 for this shootout so that we could have one last shot with the British adventurer before it slips away. Where the BMW offers a known standard of off-roading, the Tiger is another good baseline for on-road competition. The standard street bike has long-travel suspension but doesn’t pretend to love the dirt, much like the dated Aprilia Caponord and Suzuki V-Strom 1000, which is why they weren't selected.

You will see that our scorecard singles out individual traits that separate each machine’s capabilities into quantifiable categories. Objective, measurable categories include: Horsepower, Torque, Curb Weight, Range, MPG and Price. Our trio of testers, through their own personal lenses, then inspected the following: Engine Performance, Transmission/Clutch, Suspension/Handling, Brakes, Ergonomics, Fit & Finish/Instrumentation, Appearance and Grin Factor. We also included Touring Abilities and Off-Road Abilities which encompass all of the subjective categories, plus some of the finer details which are otherwise unaccounted for, such as wheel size, protection and thoughtfulness of design, for example.

Let’s dig in.

Triumph Tiger 1050 Shootout Photos
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Slideshow
Ducati MTS 1200 Shootout Photo Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Slideshow
BMW R1200GS Shootout Photo Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Slideshow

Login or sign up to comment.

John -Where's the KTM 990?  October 2, 2010 12:59 PM
I agree that these bikes are not really that great for heavy off road riding but are great for what they show in the video.
But why was the KTM not included in this as well?
John -SUV motorcycles  October 1, 2010 09:45 AM
Take any of those bikes, put them on top of a dirt hill and knock them over. Attempt to ride them home... the BMW will have busted up cylinder heads, the Triumph will have a toasted radiator, toasted exhaust and engine cases...Ducati will have trashed exhaust, plastic etc. Basically street bikes that are way too heavy, too complex, to delicate to be knocked over off-road. Call them what they are... poser bikes! Perfect for the off-road wanna-be off-roaders to match their lowered SUVs...all the looks but almost no capability. Why not take an air cooled vertical twin 450 to 650cc, fuel inject it, throw it in a frame with bash guards and 8" of suspension travel? Put a mild overdrive for 6th gear and a low, low first gear (start in second on the street) Belt drive or chain...tuck an oil cooler in the frame somewhere and make all that plastic optional? So our choice is engineering from the 80's with big thumpers or poser porker bikes that can't off-road? No wonder the motorcycling industry is in the crapper... cruisers, rockets and poser bikes--what about something light, useful, durable and handles well that won't cost $2K when it falls over?
Dusty Roads -Missing bikes  September 29, 2010 03:29 AM
Very dissapointed you folks left Suzuki V-Strom out and countless others.
AT LEAST the V-Strom should have been in it.
Louis -The V-Strom is it for me...  September 28, 2010 08:29 PM
I agree with Jim. I was thinking of how my V-Strom 650 is better than a BMW R1200GS, or a KTM 990 SMT. First of all, I can actually afford the Suzuki, it is probably more reliable, in some cases the maintenance is less often and less expensive, it gets better gas mileage, and it has a ton of aftermarket support and dedicated accessories. I guess I'll get blown off the road by the others, but I wouldn't have bought the 'Strom if I really cared about that. In fact, if the V-Strom didn't exist I would now own a Kawasaki Versys. I'm just glad there are great bikes no matter what you can afford.
Jim -The Man  September 28, 2010 11:42 AM
None of those bikes comes close to the value per dollar or competence of a V-Strom 650. Der Alpen Konig rules! When and if I wear mine out, I'll get another one. There simply is no other logical choice. Forget that high priced, high maintenance crap. Get a bike for the real world. Am I a Strom Snob? U betcha!