Drag site icon to your taskbar to pin site. Learn More

Single Track Mind: Where to Ducati?

Thursday, May 9, 2013

Nicky Hayden is the last American to claim a title in Grand Prix, way back in 2006. But his results as the longest-tenured Ducati rider have been far from title-contending.
Which Way to Jump Ducati? The Rumor Mill is Working Double Shifts

One of the advantages of having spent a life-time around GP racing is that you develop a network of other ancients who both gossip a lot and tend to be rather well informed. I got talking to one such wrinkly, and very knowledgeable, veteran at the British Superbike round at Oulton Park, and he had just returned from a very entertaining, not to say interesting, MotoGP race at Jerez.

Amongst the cognoscenti in Spain, there is a very interesting, and highly credible, story in circulation. However I must stress that, at this stage, it is nothing more than well-informed paddock gossip. Here’s the situation.

First, things are not well at Ducati. The German owners of this famous marque have sat down and reached a firm conclusion regarding ever winning a World Championship with their current line-up of riders. Quite simply, they are never going to do it no matter how good the Ducati Desmosedici GP13 becomes.

Nicky Hayden, lovely, courteous, hard working and talented though he is will never, ever run with the Aliens.
Andrea Dovizioso is better, but not greatly so. When Audi fixes the GP13, which they will, Andrea may well be a podium challenger and could even win an occasional GP. But a place on the podium does not make a World Championship contender.

To become World Champion means that your man has to be on the pace for Pole, fastest lap, and a win at every single GP – Europe, America, Asia or wherever. Wet, cold, baking hot or in floodlights, you must be there.

You have to rock up not with the hope of being competitive but rather with a confident chance of winning. That’s what Honda has with Pedrosa and Marquez and what Yamaha has with Lorenzo.

Incredibly talented though he is, Andrea does not meet these criteria.

So where does this put Audi/Ducati? The answer is in a serious dilemma. First, Marquez cannot be bought at any money because he is on a two-year contract. The same applies to Lorenzo. This leaves Dani. If he wins the World Championship, and I am skeptical of this happening, Honda will not let him go to another factory with the #1 plate.
If he doesn’t, Ducati will get another rider who is a GP winner – but not a World Championship contender.

Ducati now starts to run out of options. The first, and most obvious, choice is Cal Crutchlow. I have always tipped Cal as a seriously class act and he is now proving to be the fastest of the satellite riders race after race. He is also crawling up the wall with frustration riding machines which, while good, are not the best.

At Jerez, despite being battered and bruised from two enormous crashes, Crutchlow was still on the pace. If he had machinery of the same standard as Rossi and Pedrosa he would be challenging for the podium at every single round.

Given that Cal is so good, what went wrong with his Ducati ride for this year? There were two elements and both are embedded in what makes Cal the rider that he is. Unlike some of the current superstars, Cal comes from a very ordinary, working class background. He was not an athlete as a young man but a van driver. This tough upbringing makes him physically and mentally hard, and he likes to personify this steel in public. The real Cal, which I happen to know a little of, is almost the opposite. He is a generous, kind and thoroughly nice person. He is also polite and thoughtful – a million miles away from his public persona.

Cal Crutchlow's outspoken nature may have cost him the factory
Ducati seat in 2013. Could the new regime reverse course and
court the British rider for future campaigns?
Unfortunately, he is not nearly as media savvy as he ought to be and so when he made what might well be interpreted as intemperate comments about Ducati, as the bike was at its lowest ebb, the Bologna factory took umbrage and Dovizioso got to pocket the $3 million pay check.

Not that they needed much encouragement because the harsh truth is that Italians prefer to back Italians and so Cal’s media naivety cost him a lot of money – and a factory ride.

But that was 2012 and there is a very different sport now being played out at Ducati. To begin with, there is a not only a new owner of the famous factory but new senior staff too. The team which didn’t give Cal the ride have now gone. Of this, more a little later.

This brings us on to the touchy subject of racial stereotypes – always a dangerous area because there is no such thing as a “standard” person from any country. However, my experience of working with Germans is that they are far from the soulless automata, interested only in making money and winning, which they are often portrayed. On the contrary, I have always found the Germans to be full of fun, very humane, extremely open minded and willing to bury any prejudices they might have in order to win. Yes, they do like systems and order, but I infinitely prefer this way of working to the Italian style of smiles, hugs, fantastic lunches – and then nothing.

Is Cal likely to return to Ducati? Very, very likely – but this time he will be more controlled, more media aware and, with Germans in the team, more at home too.

Now here’s where the story gets really interesting. The wrinkly gossip is that life in Australia is not quite as perfect as Mr. C. Stoner thought it might be. Going from a world where merely having the holy Casey’s shadow fall on you was considered to be a blessing, to being just another rich, but not extremely rich, young Australian is, I am told, not sitting overly well.

Worse still, Casey looks at the current GP line-up and thinks, reportedly publicly, that he could whup all their asses regardless of what bike he rode. This may well be true, and I still believe that Stoner is one of the most naturally talented motorcycle racers of all times. Not the best, note, but the most incredibly gifted.

The flaw is that Casey needs to be loved and stroked and cared for in order to ride well. He also needs to be respected. In every degree, these are areas in which the Germans excel.

Hell would have frozen over 20 times before Casey would have ever ridden a Ducati when the old management team which, de facto, fired him was still in place. But now they’re gone and the orchestra has a different conductor.

If Casey truly is getting bored with the good life in Australia, and if he is actually itching to rejoin the pantheon of Moto Gods, then he will listen to Audi.

For their part, the Germans will tell Casey how much they respect him. They will also tell him that whatever he wants to win a World Championship he can have and, as a minor incentive, they will probably lay $15 million on the table.

Dorna, in their desperation, will weigh in everything in their toy cupboard to ensure that Casey becomes not merely very rich but truly, seriously wealthy.

Casey has already taken extreme delight in the fact that Valentino, despite his initial confidence, failed miserably with the Ducati. He will take the same pleasure in the travails of every other rider.

And if he does return, what will happen? The answer, as I and Audi both know, is utterly and completely predictable.
Casey will turn up at the first test and complain about the weather, his state of health, the color of the water in the cooler. He will then hold his head in his hands and look utterly miserable and on the point of wishing to end it all. Five minutes later, and without any familiarization, he will have put the Ducati on pole position.

This is why Audi executives will walk across the Pacific to Australia. This is why he will be loved and cherished and respected as only the Germans do for their racers. And this is why you might well see the best rider of his generation back on the MotoGP grid next year challenging for the World Championship.
2013 MotoGP Season Photo Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Gallery
View Slideshow
Recent Single Track Mind Articles
Single Track Mind: Staying Honest
Tired of seeing the history re-written, our man Melling takes vapid nostalgia to task with an honest evaluation of classic bikes both past and present.
STM: Melling Conquers LEnduro des Sables
Our man Melling recounts his poorly informed decision to enter the 1978 L'Enduro des Sables and the chaos that followed.
STM: Sammy Miller Motorcycle Museum
Our man Melling pays a call to the Sammy Miller Motorcycle Museum one of the world’s great collections of historic motorcycles.
Christmas Gifts for Your Loved One
Ye old Melling once again delivers his annual holiday gift guide for rider, which is certain to bring Yuletide marital bliss… or disaster.
STM: Storm Clouds on the Horizon
Our man Melling continues to ruminate over the future of professional motorcycle racing, and missed PR opportunities from the MotoGP ranks.

Login or sign up to comment.

GhostRider11   May 14, 2013 05:01 AM
Oh Mr. Frank, what a GREAT read this is! I agree with most of what you wrote: Hayden, Andrea, and the other Ducati riders! I feel bad for Cal too and he's showing the entire MotoGP paddock why he should be on a factory bike next year! Now onto Casey 'SUPERMAN' Stoner! I hope he does come back to MotoGP next year, he should've never 'retired' anyway! Stoner could have told HRC that he wants a year off to regroup or something. But going to Ducati??? I can't see HRC standing by with smiles on their faces allowing Stoner to ride the Ducati again especially after the final talk he had with the HRC team boss where Stoner felt he was indeed making a mistake. It would be good for MotoGP for him to be on the Ducati though. When/if Dani fails to grab the title this year... I would love to see Stoner and Marquez on equal machinery-the same Repsol RCV. Who would Stoner's old crew be with??? See if you can dig up some more gossip for us! Thanks.
Brian426v   May 13, 2013 11:50 AM
Troy Bayliss....'nough said.
proheli   May 12, 2013 10:05 PM
Casey the best of his generation? Um, no. Casey didn't even win his last year in MotoGP, and now Lorenzo and Dani are both faster. Lorenzo is faster than Casey. Marquez is faster than Casey. I like Cal. Cal is not an Alien. Cal probably won't even get past Rossi this year. Rossi has won 7 MotoGP Championships. SEEEVVEEENNN. If Casey and Lorenzo, Dani and MM all split championships one after the other, it will take 20 years before anyone gets to 7. So who gives a rats butt if Rossi ever wins another race over Casey. None of them will ever hit 7. Rossi is the GOAT. We would all like to see Casey race again. He's one of my favorites, and I love Ducati (have SFS) He's just not the best of his generation. I hope Ducati doesn't screw their current riders, it would just be too unatractive.
Desmo69   May 11, 2013 07:54 AM
Funny this article, this all depends on how much Duc/Audi actually improves the bike. If you put Cal on the Ducati he will go backwards, no doubt...adjustment period. I don't doubt his determintion I just don't see him doing any better than Nicky or Dovi or Rossi for that matter. Bringing Stoner back?? I will believe it when I see it. Would be fun to see though !!!
bikerrandy   May 10, 2013 10:00 PM
This scenario sounds like something Ducati would do if they are still the same company. It's what they hoped for with Rossi and it didn't happen. Ducati doesn't like being told it's bike is not competitive.....so they get a ringer like Stoner to make their bike look good. He's already done it before.
AnthonyD   May 10, 2013 05:45 PM
Pretty weak if Casey only takes one season off after claiming retirement. Who does he think he is, Jay-Z?
Moondog   May 10, 2013 05:36 PM
The fact is Stoner can ride the beast and win! End of story , Casey is the man. For some reason the bike and Casey clik, that's all that matters. For sure if Stoner was managed by Audi things would happen fast, very fast. I think the fact he can ride it and win adds to his reputation when others fail. Helps if you are slightly indifferent to who you are riding for, not in complete awe of the Ducati myth?
RENDELL   May 10, 2013 03:38 PM
Casey Stoner complains about everything too much. I saw him crying like a newborn baby in Faster 2. I hoped Ben Spies could run with the aliens then beat their little, skinny asses to the checkered flag.
RaZoR   May 10, 2013 09:13 AM
This clown must be Cal Crutchlows biggest fan,I guess He missed the 2012 season when Dovi dominated Cal on the same bike? British fans are hard up for a hero!! Now Stoner back on a Ducati that is interesting....but I do think Honda have left the door open for Casey anytime he wants to return.
Saint Nick   May 9, 2013 03:34 PM
Unless Ducati can build a competitive narrow angle V4 and supply a chassis that works (numerous frames, just like Honda & Yamaha) even the great CS (and he has always been my favorite rider) will fail to win another world title. Plus I believe he would rather go back to Honda (and win) or even to Suzuki (if the bike turns out to be competitive) Money is not everything to him (which is obvious) But then I am not so sure he will ever return...